Question:
Thanks Laura, for your most extraordinary post. Ginger has just had the GI series and is awaiting results. Your observation about vomitting will get my special attention. My prayers are with you and your family always. Nick C "Laura Wallace" <lewsl…@home.com
wrote in message
news:BbsO6.55213$I5.12154803@news1.rdc1.tn.home.com…
Dear Nick, I am glad to hear from you, glad your lady friend has you in her life and that you care enough to be searching for help for her. IBS is an
insidious
(sp?) disease and robs the sufferrer of health, mobility, intimacy and lastly HOPE. When things are at their worst, the pain and isolation lead
to
such hopelessness. Even as a Christian, it was a great struggle to hang
on
and believe there could be a God who’d allow such suffering of the presumably "innocent". One’s mind gravitates to such thoughts when one is in utter despair and desperation. Without someone who cares, some folks slide into permanent depression.
(snipped) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –
Response:
In article <SnyQ6.1493$rD3.265…@news.total.net
, "Charles Shahar"
<charl…@total.net
writes: Well, the tone is changing somewhat. I appreciate that. My intention was only to share my personal experiences, in the hope that others can offer insights and help my understanding progress. The two last postings suggest that there are IBS people out there with similar concerns, who perhaps have traveled a similar road. Let’s be open and tolerant to different viewpoints. Otherwise this NG will become a monopoly for a certain way of thinking and dealing with the problem of IBS. I would also appreciate if people would avoid making personal or derogatory remarks. These are hurtful, in my opinion
As long as your clear that your sharing your personal experience rather than labeling IBSers I’d like to hear about it. (your first post set me off because it had that you are all a bunch of whiners without any indication that you were a fellow sufferer or had any understanding of IBS) Once again coming from "I have found" type statements rather than appearing to say "you are a…… " without knowing anything about who is here will work better. One point is that IBS effects 20% of the population, so any generalization is likely to not fit a substantial portion of IBSers you talk to, and fit at least someone else. Some people try to generalize any number of neurotic tendancies to IBSers or to other IBSers and none of the generalizations are true. Some IBSers have some neurotic tendancies just like some people with ANY disorder will have that AND have neurotic tendancies. It has been a pretty long hard battle to convince anyone that IBS is a physical disorder rather than just one more sign that the individual is neurotic. That IBS is a predominately female disorder helps to back the it’s just the hysterical people that get it attitude that is still all too prevelant. The history of IBS as a psychological abnormality is a long one (back in the early part of the century people were thought to have IBS because we had a over-idealized notion of what the perfect BM would look like and were neurotic about not being able to produce the perfect BM) and has, IMO, kept people out of doing research into treating IBS and even taking it seriously and I’d hate to see anything return us to the days of "get over it" and you’ll be fine. K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
Longtime lurker chiming in: First off, I was diagnosed with IBS a year ago. I immediately found this newsgroup and have lurked (although I’m a regular, longime poster in several other usenet groups.) I just started reading this thread, as I’d been away from my computer for the holiday. I read this first post and was very interested to see some discussion about any links between the anxiety issues and IBS symptoms. However, it seemed to disintegrate into unpleasantness, mostly based on how some people interpreted his tone/posting style. His tone was a bit clinical and with his background in psych, he used some of the jargon…jargon that are clearly hot topics and viewed by some as negative and as labeling. I’m an IBS sufferer, and I have anxiety issues…and I do experience an exacerbation of my symptoms, regardless of my treatment, when I am having periods of stress and anxiety. In fact, I’ve had stress related GI probs for most of my life. I’m not mentioning this to be whining about it…simply pointing out that I felt that the connection he was trying to make was, to me, a valid one. I do not consider myself a "nut case" nor did I feel that was what Charles was implying. I identified with the issues he brought before the group and hoped for some dialogue. Just some thoughts. Some of you made it clear that none of those traits are you at all…it’s clearly not a connection for everyone. However, some of us who are suffering do see a connection, and I personally don’t find mention of some of my coping behaviours (and some of them *are* maladaptive) and stress disorders offensive. *shrug* They are just things I have to work on. We all have things we have to work on. After reading this thread, I feel as though I have to qualify every statement I make…I hope that my post is met with the tolerance and understanding that we are all striving for… Marcy
Response:
Well, the tone is changing somewhat. I appreciate that. My intention was only to share my personal experiences, in the hope that others can offer insights and help my understanding progress. The two last postings suggest that there are IBS people out there with similar concerns, who perhaps have traveled a similar road. Let’s be open and tolerant to different viewpoints. Otherwise this NG will become a monopoly for a certain way of thinking and dealing with the problem of IBS. I would also appreciate if people would avoid making personal or derogatory remarks. These are hurtful, in my opinion. -Charles Leechwrangler <leechwrang…@aol.com
wrote in message
news:20010528015904.29241.00003223@ng-fi1.aol.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Longtime lurker chiming in: First off, I was diagnosed with IBS a year ago. I immediately found this newsgroup and have lurked (although I’m a regular, longime poster in
several
other usenet groups.) I just started reading this thread, as I’d been away from my computer for
the
holiday. I read this first post and was very interested to see some
discussion
about any links between the anxiety issues and IBS symptoms. However, it seemed to disintegrate into unpleasantness, mostly based on how some
people
interpreted his tone/posting style. His tone was a bit clinical and with
his
background in psych, he used some of the jargon…jargon that are clearly
hot
topics and viewed by some as negative and as labeling. I’m an IBS sufferer, and I have anxiety issues…and I do experience an exacerbation of my symptoms, regardless of my treatment, when I am having periods of stress and anxiety. In fact, I’ve had stress related GI probs
for
most of my life. I’m not mentioning this to be whining about it…simply pointing out that I felt that the connection he was trying to make was, to
me,
a valid one. I do not consider myself a "nut case" nor did I feel that was what Charles
was
implying. I identified with the issues he brought before the group and
hoped
for some dialogue. Just some thoughts. Some of you made it clear that none of those traits
are
you at all…it’s clearly not a connection for everyone. However, some of
us
who are suffering do see a connection, and I personally don’t find mention
of
some of my coping behaviours (and some of them *are* maladaptive) and
stress
disorders offensive. *shrug* They are just things I have to work on. We
all
have things we have to work on. After reading this thread, I feel as though I have to qualify every
statement I
make…I hope that my post is met with the tolerance and understanding
that we
are all striving for… Marcy
Response:
Charles, Just wanted to tell you that I understand what you are trying to convey to the NG participants. With any physical illness, it is important to remain positive. Sometimes this seems much easier said than done, but it is necessary for complete healing with ANY condition. Unfortunately, these posters failed to read your entire message. If all of you read the attached message from Charles COMPLETELY, you will see that he doesn’t imply that it is ALL emotional. He merely suggests that you can grow emotionally as you heal the physical problem. Charles is obviously a sufferer as well; otherwise, he wouldn’t waste his time posting to this newsgroup. He isn’t trying to sell anything, only trying to help us. I think that some of you owe him an apology. Maybe this IBS is causing some of us to become too sensitive.
Subject: Re: IBS & Personality Styles
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
From: "Charles Shahar" charl…@total.net Date: 05/20/2001 7:17 PM Eastern Daylight Time Message-id: <NhYN6.1316$0A.185…@news.total.net To Laura and KM: Actually KM, from the tone of your message, you don’t seem to have problems asserting your opinions. My mistake about implying passive-aggressive behavior to IBS sufferers. :-) Seriously though, I wish to make the following points: I think you are both great contributors to the IBS discussion of this NG. However, I don’t agree with the overemphasis on the physical side of IBS. In fact, in some ways it is a disservice to readers. The problem is that people will wait for a little blue pill to be discovered. They can be waiting most of their lives. I think that is a waste, putting one’s life on hold like that. I think IBS is actually a voyage of discovery, from a mental and physical perspective. The body is trying to get your attention… FOR A REASON. It is telling you something. And since I believe very strongly that EVERY ILLNESS is a spiritual and emotional odyssey, there is much to be gained from the journey of self-discovery that one embarks on. Please don’t get me wrong. One should continue to look for ways to alleviate their problem. No way should they accept it. But the solution, just like the problem, lies on many levels!!! And even if a little blue pill is discovered (please know that I am praying for that to happen), I strongly believe that if the emotional antecedents are not dealt with, they will manifest in other ways. Whatever negative emotions or thoughts are involved, take your pick, they will manifest physically in other ways. The mind and body are so intimately linked, it is hard to believe that these emotions will just go away along with the illness. As I said, this is a complicated issue. Cancer has an emotional component, but it can also have a strictly environmental cause. I cannot believe that the emotional component to IBS strictly happens after the fact. The bottom line is that IBS is a problem, but it is also an opportunity. Certainly one should wait for a blue pill to come along… but also heed the body’s messages. There are some subtle lessons to be learned as well. Lessons little blue pills won’t solve. -Charles
Response:
Thank you K, for the links. I have passed on the suggestion of Caltrate (from Laura). Also, (coincidence?) a news piece on a breakthrough in Chron’s disease was aired the other nite. A University of Chicago research project has shown promising results in the use of Remicade for that illness, albeit some severe side effects. I am curious about the linkage and similarities of Chron’s and IBS. Nick C "KMottus" <kmot…@aol.comspamtrap
wrote in message
news:20010522081256.10634.00001658@nso-cd.aol.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
In article <3b0966f…@news.starnetinc.com, "Niko" <theo…@jglinc.com writes: She had been to doctors, has been told and has convinced herself that
there
is no cure. She has given in to the pain, and has lost hope of getting
any
relief. She has effectively hidden this from most of her friends, family
and
even the medical professionals she works with. After hearing her describe "IBS" (I had never even heard the term before), I started researching on
the
net and newsgroups, and here I am. I have found more support and
information
in 2 weeks than she has in 2 years Since she has a medical background encourage her to look on Medline. Alot of research has been going on the last few years and seeing that may help her decide on some treatment options to try. They may not be cures, but can greatly reduce suffering. If your lucky, maybe on of the IBS researchers will be in your area, and seeing a doctor who is also working on treatments for a disease can make a big difference. Even finding a good GI person in your area that has good bedside manner and likes working with IBS patients can make a big difference (www.iffgd.org is the international foundation that includes IBS in their focus on functional GI disorders, they may be able to recommend someone in your area). That IBS has no cure and no viable treatments is the conventional wisdom from some time ago and is not the current thinking on this disease (if it was the drug companies wouldn’t be working on a number of drugs specifically for treating IBS). Also have her read the :"Living with IBS" section of the bb on www.ibsgroup.org. My story is there as well as several other peoples. Many people do find things that make huge differeneces in the disorder and maybe reading some sucess stories will help her have some hope, and some things she may want to talk to her doctor about trying. K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
Cheers for all your support and research on your girlfriend’s behalf!! bb – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Niko wrote:
Laura, I read your very insightful post, and had to reply. My girlfriend is 5 years with IBS. I never knew about it until 3 weeks ago when she had an unusually severe episode at my mother’s house. I had only seen her collapse into vomitting, diahrrea, etc. twice before, and she told me it was food poisoning both times (we had been out to eat). This time, it was mom’s home cooking, and she was out for 3 hours after the initial purging, followed by severe tremors, high body temp variation, etc. We were readly to call an ambulance (she’s a nurse, BTW) and she confessed the history of this to me, much to my shock. She has had weekly episodes for about 2 years. She had been to doctors, has been told and has convinced herself that there is no cure. She has given in to the pain, and has lost hope of getting any relief. She has effectively hidden this from most of her friends, family and even the medical professionals she works with. After hearing her describe "IBS" (I had never even heard the term before), I started researching on the net and newsgroups, and here I am. I have found more support and information in 2 weeks than she has in 2 years. I am replying to point out that there are those (many?) who HAVE given up, lost their will to fight, and suffer terribly in silence. To forget them or deny their existence is a disservice to the fight for a cure. We must realize that for every victim with the resources to participate in an internet-based newsgroup discussion about IBS, there are a dozen who cannot, and become isolated from support. I believe you are a caring and loving person who gives much to relieve the suffering of others. Your participation in this discussion proves this out. My task is to follow your lead, and bring my friend back into the realm of hope for a cure for this disease. Nick C "Laura Wallace" <lewsl…@home.com wrote in message news:uJ0O6.49418$I5.11013967@news1.rdc1.tn.home.com… Regarding "little blue miracle pills" and "the spiritual odyssey" that IBS affords: I hate to speak for others, Charles, but I don’t know a single IBS sufferer who does nothing other than wait for a "cure"… We have all explored every possible solution, anything that hinted at helping our situation because our "situation", our disease, our disorder, our suffering is horrible! I don’t know of anyone who has simply given in to the pain and discomfort and isolation etc that comes with our malady. Indeed, that is why we are on this newsgroup, to share, to explore and to SEARCH continually for answers. To believe that IBS or cancer or a broken leg is a "spiritual journey" without seeing it as a body dealing with illness or trauma is stupid. All of life is a spiritual journey, yes, I agree with that. But, that does not make having coffee in the morning a religious experience…. rather, our connection with our individuality, our holiness because of a loving, forgiving God etc, that makes all of life’s moments a religious journey. You do the "readers" a disservice if all you have to offer is that we should see our suffering as an opportunity for growth. Granted, it is an opportunity, but it is also a concrete PHYSICAL situation and that suffering is so intense at times, it overshadows any "spiritual" moments you may feel are imbedded in this chapter of life. To shame someone because they are seeking relief from their pain and misery and depression from IBS because they are not spending their energy on "knowing themselves" better, is the disservice, Charles. Here I am, having found that Caltrate (not a blue pill by the way) has resolved my symptoms… and yet, I’m here. Why then, Charles if I am only after a cure, would I still be in this forum? I don’t just "preach" Caltrate… because it doesn’t work for everyone. I am here because I found support and acceptance and suggestions of things to try that might help. I am here because HOPEFULLY, I can say something that will help someone else… There is no "blue pill" for some people… but our genuine concern and caring can be more powerful than a "blue pill". I dare say, if you suffered physically as most of us have, you would not be able to make such comments about us focussing on the "physical" side of IBS. Good Grief, man! IBS is a physical malady. There are indeed emotional and psychological ramifications, but it is not "in our heads". It is NOT a matter of our being wusses who whine at every twinge of gut pain. Truly, a man who is in physical pain cannot focus on the spiritual side of things effectively until his phsyical needs are addressed. Ever try to teach a child who is starving? Christ taught us to meet physical needs AND spiritual needs. A man cannot eat parables. Stop harrassing us because we HOPE for cures… Some days HOPE is all we have to keep insanity from the door. It would be so easy to give in to despair. IBS is incurable… it is horrible and IT is what has put our lives on hold, not US. Don’t preach about disservice to the "readers". We are family, united in our common suffering. When we support each other and share our pain and our joys, the only disservice comes from someone who can’t join in our suffering and therefore, can’t join in our joys when one of us finds relief. If you cannot help, Charles, then do NOT hinder. We have enough to bear. Laura W
Response:
I believe IBS is some kind of physical problem that science just has not discovered an answer for yet. I am one of those persons who had a previous health problem (blood clotting), and it was suggested that my lifestyle may have been the contributing factor. Lo’ and behold’, in 1993 they discovered a gene for Factor V Leiden, which is a mutation at the DNA level, and I tested positive for it. It felt so good to know that nothing I could have done, lifestyle-wise, would have changed the outcome. The question is why so many people with Factor V Leiden do not have blood clotting episodes or health problems. One theory is that it may take an additional gene mutation (separate from Factor V Leiden) working concurrently with Factor V Leiden to cause medical problems. It will probably end up being a similar discovery for IBS patients, perhaps a combination of factors. bb – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Charles Shahar wrote:
To Laura and KM: Actually KM, from the tone of your message, you don’t seem to have problems asserting your opinions. My mistake about implying passive-aggressive behavior to IBS sufferers. :-) Seriously though, I wish to make the following points: I think you are both great contributors to the IBS discussion of this NG. However, I don’t agree with the overemphasis on the physical side of IBS. In fact, in some ways it is a disservice to readers. The problem is that people will wait for a little blue pill to be discovered. They can be waiting most of their lives. I think that is a waste, putting one’s life on hold like that. I think IBS is actually a voyage of discovery, from a mental and physical perspective. The body is trying to get your attention… FOR A REASON. It is telling you something. And since I believe very strongly that EVERY ILLNESS is a spiritual and emotional odyssey, there is much to be gained from the journey of self-discovery that one embarks on. Please don’t get me wrong. One should continue to look for ways to alleviate their problem. No way should they accept it. But the solution, just like the problem, lies on many levels!!! And even if a little blue pill is discovered (please know that I am praying for that to happen), I strongly believe that if the emotional antecedents are not dealt with, they will manifest in other ways. Whatever negative emotions or thoughts are involved, take your pick, they will manifest physically in other ways. The mind and body are so intimately linked, it is hard to believe that these emotions will just go away along with the illness. As I said, this is a complicated issue. Cancer has an emotional component, but it can also have a strictly environmental cause. I cannot believe that the emotional component to IBS strictly happens after the fact. The bottom line is that IBS is a problem, but it is also an opportunity. Certainly one should wait for a blue pill to come along… but also heed the body’s messages. There are some subtle lessons to be learned as well. Lessons little blue pills won’t solve. -Charles
Response:
Charles, You will end up being like most of us, spending years trying to find something that helps. Eventually, you will have some success. It is the discovery process (what helps, what makes it worse) that is so darned frustrating. You do need to keep working with your doctors because they may eventually find a contributing factor. In my case, after many tests, and years of wasted time, they did find a fat malabsorption problem, and the enzymes prescribed help dramatically. bb – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Charles Shahar wrote:
I am really sorry to be getting this response. I know about the physical pain associated with IBS. I have had it since 1981, which is for about 20 years. It is my struggle to come to grips with this illness which has led me to explore myself in ways I probably would not have otherwise. However, I have taken your comments about smugness quite seriously, and will do some reflecting about it. I have obviously not been sensitive to the suffering of others, and I apologize. Your struggles deserve better. Regarding my parents paying for my rent… I actually live in a basement flat. I work diminished hours because IBS has taught me some implications related to job burnout. My mobility is affected by my illness. I can’t go on long trips, and I can’t live with the girl I love because my life isn’t normal. Anyway, why get into the limitations? I was trying to focus on the positive side, but failed miserably. I hope you all find peace with your problems. Those people who help others in this NG are doing everyone a great service. If you don’t mind, I would like to drop this thread. It has generated enough negativity. So why don’t we move on… Thanks, Charles Laura Wallace <lewsl…@home.com wrote in message news:uJ0O6.49418$I5.11013967@news1.rdc1.tn.home.com… Regarding "little blue miracle pills" and "the spiritual odyssey" that IBS affords: I hate to speak for others, Charles, but I don’t know a single IBS sufferer who does nothing other than wait for a "cure"… We have all explored every possible solution, anything that hinted at helping our situation because our "situation", our disease, our disorder, our suffering is horrible! I don’t know of anyone who has simply given in to the pain and discomfort and isolation etc that comes with our malady. Indeed, that is why we are on this newsgroup, to share, to explore and to SEARCH continually for answers. To believe that IBS or cancer or a broken leg is a "spiritual journey" without seeing it as a body dealing with illness or trauma is stupid. All of life is a spiritual journey, yes, I agree with that. But, that does not make having coffee in the morning a religious experience…. rather, our connection with our individuality, our holiness because of a loving, forgiving God etc, that makes all of life’s moments a religious journey. You do the "readers" a disservice if all you have to offer is that we should see our suffering as an opportunity for growth. Granted, it is an opportunity, but it is also a concrete PHYSICAL situation and that suffering is so intense at times, it overshadows any "spiritual" moments you may feel are imbedded in this chapter of life. To shame someone because they are seeking relief from their pain and misery and depression from IBS because they are not spending their energy on "knowing themselves" better, is the disservice, Charles. Here I am, having found that Caltrate (not a blue pill by the way) has resolved my symptoms… and yet, I’m here. Why then, Charles if I am only after a cure, would I still be in this forum? I don’t just "preach" Caltrate… because it doesn’t work for everyone. I am here because I found support and acceptance and suggestions of things to try that might help. I am here because HOPEFULLY, I can say something that will help someone else… There is no "blue pill" for some people… but our genuine concern and caring can be more powerful than a "blue pill". I dare say, if you suffered physically as most of us have, you would not be able to make such comments about us focussing on the "physical" side of IBS. Good Grief, man! IBS is a physical malady. There are indeed emotional and psychological ramifications, but it is not "in our heads". It is NOT a matter of our being wusses who whine at every twinge of gut pain. Truly, a man who is in physical pain cannot focus on the spiritual side of things effectively until his phsyical needs are addressed. Ever try to teach a child who is starving? Christ taught us to meet physical needs AND spiritual needs. A man cannot eat parables. Stop harrassing us because we HOPE for cures… Some days HOPE is all we have to keep insanity from the door. It would be so easy to give in to despair. IBS is incurable… it is horrible and IT is what has put our lives on hold, not US. Don’t preach about disservice to the "readers". We are family, united in our common suffering. When we support each other and share our pain and our joys, the only disservice comes from someone who can’t join in our suffering and therefore, can’t join in our joys when one of us finds relief. If you cannot help, Charles, then do NOT hinder. We have enough to bear. Laura W
Response:
In article <jm9O6.1395$0A.215…@news.total.net
, "Charles Shahar"
<charl…@total.net
writes: I am really sorry to be getting this response. I know about the physical pain associated with IBS. I have had it since 1981, which is for about 20 years. It is my struggle to come to grips with this illness which has led me to explore myself in ways I probably would not have otherwise. However, I have taken your comments about smugness quite seriously, and will do some reflecting about it. I have obviously not been sensitive to the suffering of others, and I apologize. Your struggles deserve better.
Ok, cool, your a fellow sufferer. In the future, it helps to share that information when you discuss IBS. There are an awful lot of people who have spiritualities that tend to the you could be well if only you wanted to be well which is a perversion of the mind-body aspects of medicine, and much of what you wrote appeared to be a healthy person telling us sick people that we could be better if we had the right postitive attitude about being sick. While attitude makes a big difference in healing, one needs to be careful in how one works with sick people as it is all too easy to come off as "your sick because you either don’t want to be well or are too lazy to be well". By setting the stage for your insights from being a fellow sufferer, and sharing personally (the telling the story from the first person perspective rather than if you would do perspective) is generally much more effective and works much better in communicating your ideas. If you share your struggle from your own experience it opens more doors than when you appear to be telling people what to do. The I’ve noticed that when I work on the following aspects of my personalitiy I can control my IBS better would play much better. The other problem is that had you delivered your message in person we would have had body language and other clues to figure out the underlying meaning of your words–the where you were coming from. You words seemed to be coming from someone who never had IBS but was really pissed off at the people in his life that did. Sick of them not going places with him, Sick of them not getting well because he though they should get well. Primarily because the writing style and the tone of the words is similiar to people who feel that way. <just a bit of arm chair psychology–ignore if it doesn’t fit your situation
I understand being angry about IBS, but if you are angry with yourself about having this disorder I hope that you can forgive yourself (sometimes we appear to be angry or superior to others because of attitudes we hold about ourselfs)
Regarding my parents paying for my rent… I actually live in a basement flat. I work diminished hours because IBS has taught me some implications related to job burnout. My mobility is affected by my illness. I can’t go on long trips, and I can’t live with the girl I love because my life isn’t normal. Anyway, why get into the limitations? I was trying to focus on the positive side, but failed miserably.
What may work is for you to talk about what you did, your insights how they affected you. The ya’ll should work on yourselves without the information that you are doing the same comes across badly.
I hope you all find peace with your problems. Those people who help others in this NG are doing everyone a great service. If you don’t mind, I would like to drop this thread. It has generated enough negativity. So why don’t we move on…
K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
Yes, all but the passive-agressive part. I tend to be fairly direct. btw I was subscribed as eclectic…@earthlink.net had to dump that so I’m not a newbie. been lurking for months. leaving my job this friday and it is at least in part due to IBS
Response:
Charles, I personally do not think there are any psychological contributing factors except for moderate stress, which only makes an already existing bad situation even worse. Of course, at times when there was stress (like attending a job interview or sitting in the dentist’s chair), nothing happens. Look at some of the events and locations some of us have had where this stuff kicked in. Let’s try just after a shower when you still have shampoo in your hair. That is not the time I want to exit the tub. There is nothing on my mind at the time other than washing. Some of the times and locations just do not make sense. The only thing I find interesting is how that it rarely wakes a person from sleep. bb – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Charles Shahar wrote:
Has any research been done on IBS and personality styles? Having a clinical psychology background, I can’t help but analyze this connection. For instance, does any of the following sound familiar to IBS sufferers: Martyr Complex Inability to adequately express needs Conflict avoidance Social anxiety, particularly related to not measuring-up Passive-aggressive style etc. Ring a bell for anyone? -Charles
Response:
In article <3b0966f…@news.starnetinc.com
, "Niko" <theo…@jglinc.com
writes:
She had been to doctors, has been told and has convinced herself that there is no cure. She has given in to the pain, and has lost hope of getting any relief. She has effectively hidden this from most of her friends, family and even the medical professionals she works with. After hearing her describe "IBS" (I had never even heard the term before), I started researching on the net and newsgroups, and here I am. I have found more support and information in 2 weeks than she has in 2 years
Since she has a medical background encourage her to look on Medline. Alot of research has been going on the last few years and seeing that may help her decide on some treatment options to try. They may not be cures, but can greatly reduce suffering. If your lucky, maybe on of the IBS researchers will be in your area, and seeing a doctor who is also working on treatments for a disease can make a big difference. Even finding a good GI person in your area that has good bedside manner and likes working with IBS patients can make a big difference (www.iffgd.org is the international foundation that includes IBS in their focus on functional GI disorders, they may be able to recommend someone in your area). That IBS has no cure and no viable treatments is the conventional wisdom from some time ago and is not the current thinking on this disease (if it was the drug companies wouldn’t be working on a number of drugs specifically for treating IBS). Also have her read the :"Living with IBS" section of the bb on www.ibsgroup.org. My story is there as well as several other peoples. Many people do find things that make huge differeneces in the disorder and maybe reading some sucess stories will help her have some hope, and some things she may want to talk to her doctor about trying. K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
Dear Nick, I am glad to hear from you, glad your lady friend has you in her life and that you care enough to be searching for help for her. IBS is an insidious (sp?) disease and robs the sufferrer of health, mobility, intimacy and lastly HOPE. When things are at their worst, the pain and isolation lead to such hopelessness. Even as a Christian, it was a great struggle to hang on and believe there could be a God who’d allow such suffering of the presumably "innocent". One’s mind gravitates to such thoughts when one is in utter despair and desperation. Without someone who cares, some folks slide into permanent depression. I must admit that before I found calcium for my IBS, and it doesn’t help everyone, I had only a few folks who knew about my condition and whom I could talk to. My older sister suffers but not nearly as severely or as often. I would talk to her sometimes but even she had a difficult time understanding why I couldn’t just take Imodium and be okay in a couple of hours like her… But, some of us suffer worse cases. I’ve had IBS for 20 years… and it didn’t start out so severe… but by last summer, before calcium, I was having daily episodes which often lasted for hours. In order to leave the house for more than 20 minutes, I had to fast (STARVE) for 24-48 hours AND take an Imodium as an extra precaution. Generally, if my husband and I had to make a trip, I fasted for the entire trip…. if I ate anything during the time away from home, it was followed by 2 Imodium tablets. So, after we returned home, I expected and got several days of killer diarrhea and cramps… emptying for days. This was quite a lot to put my body through. My husband has dairy intolerance so there are times when he has a "reaction" to eating cheese or something and has diarrhea and gas etc… So, he had a small idea of what fun IBS was… We discussed IBS before we got far into the relationship… He just didn’t realize how big a deal it was in my life. During our five year marriage, we have missed out on many things because of my illness… including a trip to the Olympics when they were in Atlanta – about 2 hours from my home. He’s wanted to take me all over the country, site seeing… but alas, I could not go. The few trips we have made to his hometown in Kentucky to visit his family have been an ordeal for me. IBS does strongly impact relationships. It is tough knowing that because of my illness, my husband and children have missed out on fun, educational things… It has taken quite a lot to be able to let it go, to realize I have done my best and can’t be blamed for the illness. It is not like I could change it or choose NOT to be sick. If I could, I would. Children don’t understand when they are young though… they do resent mommy for always being sick. They wind up going on fun trips with other family members, my sisters or brother or with my husband and not me etc. Someone else raised my children… because I was most often in the bathroom or in bed crying with cramps. What a sad legacy. The sadness and depression can be crippling. But, God led me to the newsgroup last year… It is a long story but suffice it to say, I had taken all I could bear and had a gun and was gonna end my suffering when God whispered in my ear that I had not tried EVERYTHING… He reminded me of a comment I’d heard… an old wive’s tale about calcium. At that moment, I prayed and told God, that I would not take my life because he gave it to me… and that I would find out about calcium. It was a turning point for me. From there, I got online and searched furiously for info on calcium and IBS… that’s when I found this newsgroup. Within a week, I had been told all about calcium and what some folks claimed… I’d heard from KMottus about the "technical" side of it and from LNAPE about the personal side of it …. and I felt so supported by the folks in the newsgroup that I knew things had to be better even if calcium didn’t work for me. There were now folks who suffered, who knew what I was going through and who cared and wanted to help… with suggestion after suggestion, with technical info and personal stories to back it up. When the calcium WORKED for me, I knew it was not by accident – neither the calcium nor finding the newsgroup. I knew that this was a wonderful gift and one that I had a responsibility to share. I have counseled 5 people who have emailed me from reading my story on my webpage… and all five have had relief with calcium, three have had 100% relief like me and the other two people have had improvement from taking calcium but still have some attacks that are not as frequent nor as horrible. Additionally, I was given the opportunity to be interviewed along with my family physician (who first mentioned the wive’s tale about calcium). We were interviewed on TV on a local station. Many folks locally have commented on the interview and asked for more details. There again though, calcium doesn’t work for everyone with IBS… but what does help everyone with IBS is having an open forum to discuss it, to whine, to debate, to explore, to share our lives, our suffering, our joys… all of it with someone who can relate and will not condemn. I still have IBS. If I miss my calcium I still get attacks without fail. Yes, I had to test it to make sure it was not just a "psychological" cure, a placebo effect. But, if I miss my calcium, I get the killer diarrhea and cramps… and once I take it again, things resolve. Nick, I have not heard of vomiting being associated with IBS. Granted, when the cramps are very severe, I get nauseated from the pain. Has your lady friend had GI tests to make sure there is nothing functionally wrong? Just because a doctor labels someone as having IBS, does not mean it is necessarily a correct diagnosis…. I’d get a second opinion… And even if the diagnosis is correct, there is support available and many suggestions from fellow sufferers that may bring some relief. Believe me, some relief is enough to give HOPE… the idea of complete resolution was ridiculous to me. I’d been told numerous times that there is NO CURE and that I’d gone through all the drugs and therapies there were to be offered. But that was not true. Just because I’d done everything the gastroenteroligst had up his sleeve did not mean there were not other ideas out there. My gastroenteroligist NEVER suggested calcium… Please, have your lady friend have a thorough GI checkup and get a second opinion for the sake of peace of mind… and then, if still sure it is IBS, ask on the newsgroup. Many of these folks have ideas of what has helped them or others… it may be a combination thing that gives her back normalcy in her life. KMottus is a rich source of info and is ALWAYS willing to discuss and suggest and listen. Many many others in here are also of great help and support. If possible, get your friend involved in the group. Having someone listen and care makes a huge impact on one’s attitude which in turn impacts overall health. My sincere hope is for all to find relief from IBS. Let me know if I can do anything at all to help. And thank you for your kind words. Laura W "Niko" <theo…@jglinc.com
wrote in message
news:3b0966f4_1@news.starnetinc.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Laura, I read your very insightful post, and had to reply. My girlfriend is 5
years
with IBS. I never knew about it until 3 weeks ago when she had an
unusually
severe episode at my mother’s house. I had only seen her collapse into vomitting, diahrrea, etc. twice before, and she told me it was food poisoning both times (we had been out to eat). This time, it was mom’s
home
cooking, and she was out for 3 hours after the initial purging, followed
by
severe tremors, high body temp variation, etc. We were readly to call an ambulance (she’s a nurse, BTW) and she confessed the history of this to
me,
much to my shock. She has had weekly episodes for about 2 years. She had been to doctors, has been told and has convinced herself that
there
is no cure. She has given in to the pain, and has lost hope of getting any relief. She has effectively hidden this from most of her friends, family
and
even the medical professionals she works with. After hearing her describe "IBS" (I had never even heard the term before), I started researching on
the
net and newsgroups, and here I am. I have found more support and
information
in 2 weeks than she has in 2 years. I am replying to point out that there are those (many?) who HAVE given up, lost their will to fight, and suffer terribly in silence. To forget them
or
deny their existence is a disservice to the fight for a cure. We must realize that for every victim with the resources to participate in an internet-based newsgroup discussion about IBS, there are a dozen who
cannot,
and become isolated from support. I believe you are a caring and loving person who gives much to relieve the suffering of others. Your participation in this discussion proves this
out. > My task is to follow your lead, and bring my friend back into the realm of > hope for a cure for this disease. > Nick C > "Laura Wallace" <lewsl…@home.com
wrote in message
> news:uJ0O6.49418$I5.11013967@news1.rdc1.tn.home.com… > > Regarding "little blue miracle pills" and "the spiritual odyssey" that IBS
affords: I hate to speak for others, Charles, but I don’t know a single IBS sufferer who does nothing other than wait for a "cure"… We have all explored every possible solution, anything that hinted at helping our situation because our "situation", our disease, our disorder, our suffering is horrible! I don’t know of anyone who has simply given in to the pain and discomfort and isolation etc that comes with our malady. Indeed, that is why we are on this newsgroup, to share, to explore and to SEARCH continually for answers.
… read more »
Response:
Has any research been done on IBS and personality styles? Having a clinical psychology background, I can’t help but analyze this connection. For instance, does any of the following sound familiar to IBS sufferers: Martyr Complex Inability to adequately express needs Conflict avoidance Social anxiety, particularly related to not measuring-up Passive-aggressive style etc. Ring a bell for anyone? -Charles
Response:
In article <gElN6.937$0A.112…@news.total.net
, "Charles Shahar"
<charl…@total.net
writes: Has any research been done on IBS and personality styles? Having a clinical psychology background, I can’t help but analyze this connection. For instance, does any of the following sound familiar to IBS sufferers:
IBS appears to occur in all personality styles. It is a physical disorder. OTOH, like all disorders there is a psychosocial aspect to the problem and some personality types may have more difficulty dealing with the symptoms, but any disorder that effects 20% of the population is likely to occur in a wide variety of psychological backgrounds. Look in the medical literature for Dr. D. Drossman’s work on the psychosocial aspects of IBS. Personally, I am generally very laid back and about the most UNanxious person I’ve ever met. Please do not spread the rumor that we are all nut cases, it is not true. People with anxiety may have a harder time dealing with IBS as the symptoms of IBS tend to be anxiety provoking even in people with normal psychologies. Pain generally raises stress and anxiety levels. K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
Hi KM: I am also a very laid back, mellow person. Very seemingly calm. But you should know as well as I do, that what a person "seems" like, and what is going on inside themselves can be quite different. An inability to express negative emotions, to hide these from others, to keep anger bottled-up… all of these are not symptoms of a "nut case", as you put it. They are simply maladaptive patterns, learned in childhood, to survive certain psychosocial conditions. While I understand how people with IBS are sensitive to labels describing them as "nut cases", I also think it would be useful for them (I am including myself) to investigate what it is about their psychological makeup that perhaps aggravates and perpetuates their condition. To say IBS is a physical disorder and to leave it at that, is a bit of denial, and prevents a person from taking a deeper look at themselves and to investigate the psychological and spiritual elements that may be in the background for their problems. I am not denying the physical causes. But the situation is complex, likely involving genetic factors, environmental factors (exposure to certain types of bacteria), physiological factors, and most certainly the way a person thinks of themselves as well. Thanks for your comments, -Charles – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
IBS appears to occur in all personality styles. It is a physical disorder. OTOH, like all disorders there is a psychosocial aspect to the problem and some personality types may have more difficulty dealing with the symptoms, but any disorder that effects 20% of the population is likely to occur in a wide variety of psychological backgrounds. Look in the medical literature for Dr. D. Drossman’s work on the psychosocial aspects of IBS. Personally, I am generally very laid back and about the most UNanxious person I’ve ever met. Please do not spread the rumor that we are all nut cases, it is not true. People with anxiety may have a harder time dealing with IBS as the symptoms of IBS tend to be anxiety provoking even in people with normal psychologies. Pain generally raises stress and anxiety levels. K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
I’ve done mind-body therapies for IBS and am quite aware of my inner states and how they match my external apperance. I’ve never been one to bottle up negative emotions or any of the other maladaptive problems you brought up. The person who did my CBT that did wonders for my IBS seemed to have the same opinion of my mental status. I didn’t have to work on personality problems but did learn how to effectively use my brain/mind to interact with the "second brain" that controls digestion (a very complex neural net that appears to be what has gone haywire in IBS). Personality can effect ALL diseases and IBS is no different than any other physical ailment. IBS is probably no more effected and no less effected than other disease. Because we haven’t had until recently had ways to measure and effect the physical aspects of the disease the interaction of the psyche and the body has been investigated. While your mental state may effect the disease it is not the cause of it. Working on the mental state and how the nerves in your brain effect and interact with the nerves controlling you GI tract can make a difference in the course of the disorder. Again, IBS is not caused by personality defects. Anxiety (and your baseline anxiety levels seems to be more of a how your brain is wired than anything eles) can make it more difficult to deal with IBS and for some people addressing the anxiety they feel can be useful. BTW do you suffer for IBS, how long, what’s worked for you in treating it. What hasn’t worked… do you have any useful information to share other than implying that were all passive agressive conflict avoiding anxious martyrs. Or just like telling IBSers what’s wrong with us. K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
Charles, I think I see where you are coming from, what you are getting at. But, though I may be uncomfortable with confrontations and grew up in a stressful environment as a child, parental alcoholism, I really cannot see where this plays a role in my IBS symptoms. Additionally, with the use of calcium, I have had nearly an entire year without IBS symptoms and have not suffered any psychological problems from the lack of IBS … I still prefer to avoid conflict… I really think that the psychological makeup of folks with IBS is completely random, initially. However, as with any ongoing/chronic illness, depression, isolationism, lowered self esteem etc come with the territory. I do not feel that nervousness or an inability to thrive in conflict CAUSES or exaserbates IBS more than any other kind of stress does, both good and bad. I really think IBS is no respector of persons… striking young and old, male and female, those with no other health problems and those with many other health problems. Again, I think the psychological component is not an indication of who is PRONE to get IBS, but rather, those who have IBS are more likely to suffer depression etc… Just like those with cancer or HIV or other devastating illnesses. Not, that I am saying IBS is as bad or worse or not as bad or worse than cancer or HIV. Every disease and illness is a hell to endure in its own right. Best wishes to you in your pondering. Laura W "Charles Shahar" <charl…@total.net
wrote in message
news:vzwN6.1082$0A.134186@news.total.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Hi KM: I am also a very laid back, mellow person. Very seemingly calm. But you should know as well as I do, that what a person "seems" like, and what is going on inside themselves can be quite different. An inability to express negative emotions, to hide these from others, to keep anger bottled-up… all of these are not symptoms of a "nut case", as you put it. They are simply maladaptive patterns, learned in childhood, to survive certain psychosocial conditions. While I understand how people with IBS are sensitive to labels describing them as "nut cases", I also think it would be useful for them (I am including myself) to investigate what it is about their psychological
makeup
that perhaps aggravates and perpetuates their condition. To say IBS is a physical disorder and to leave it at that, is a bit of denial, and
prevents
a person from taking a deeper look at themselves and to investigate the psychological and spiritual elements that may be in the background for
their
problems. I am not denying the physical causes. But the situation is complex, likely involving genetic factors, environmental factors (exposure to certain
types
of bacteria), physiological factors, and most certainly the way a person thinks of themselves as well. Thanks for your comments, -Charles IBS appears to occur in all personality styles. It is a physical disorder. OTOH, like all disorders there is a psychosocial aspect to the problem and some personality types may have more difficulty dealing with the symptoms, but any disorder that effects 20% of the population is likely to occur in a wide variety of psychological backgrounds. Look in the medical literature for Dr. D. Drossman’s work on the psychosocial aspects of IBS. Personally, I am generally very laid back and about the most UNanxious person I’ve ever met. Please do not spread the rumor that we are all nut cases, it is not true. People with anxiety may have a harder time dealing with IBS as the symptoms of IBS tend to be anxiety provoking even in people with normal psychologies. Pain generally raises stress and anxiety levels. K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
To Laura and KM: Actually KM, from the tone of your message, you don’t seem to have problems asserting your opinions. My mistake about implying passive-aggressive behavior to IBS sufferers. :-) Seriously though, I wish to make the following points: I think you are both great contributors to the IBS discussion of this NG. However, I don’t agree with the overemphasis on the physical side of IBS. In fact, in some ways it is a disservice to readers. The problem is that people will wait for a little blue pill to be discovered. They can be waiting most of their lives. I think that is a waste, putting one’s life on hold like that. I think IBS is actually a voyage of discovery, from a mental and physical perspective. The body is trying to get your attention… FOR A REASON. It is telling you something. And since I believe very strongly that EVERY ILLNESS is a spiritual and emotional odyssey, there is much to be gained from the journey of self-discovery that one embarks on. Please don’t get me wrong. One should continue to look for ways to alleviate their problem. No way should they accept it. But the solution, just like the problem, lies on many levels!!! And even if a little blue pill is discovered (please know that I am praying for that to happen), I strongly believe that if the emotional antecedents are not dealt with, they will manifest in other ways. Whatever negative emotions or thoughts are involved, take your pick, they will manifest physically in other ways. The mind and body are so intimately linked, it is hard to believe that these emotions will just go away along with the illness. As I said, this is a complicated issue. Cancer has an emotional component, but it can also have a strictly environmental cause. I cannot believe that the emotional component to IBS strictly happens after the fact. The bottom line is that IBS is a problem, but it is also an opportunity. Certainly one should wait for a blue pill to come along… but also heed the body’s messages. There are some subtle lessons to be learned as well. Lessons little blue pills won’t solve. -Charles
Response:
Charles. None of the IBSers I know or have talked with is waiting around for some future miracle pill. They are always seeking something that would help them, sometimes wisely from those who can help and sometimes unwisely from those who would take money from them for bogus cures. But they are trying. Every Day Very Hard. Again… Do you actually suffer from IBS or do you like sitting around passing judgement on us to make yourself feel superior?? K. ********************************************************* Failure is not an option, it comes packaged with the software kmot…@aol.com
Response:
The fear of shitting in your pants and seeing that fear realized even once is enough to make one’s personality fit whatever IBS model Charles has conjured up in his smug little head. Not being able to pay the rent because you haven’t been able to go to work because of your ten-second warning to get to a bathroom does wonders, as well. Who here thinks Charles’ parents pay his bills?
Response:
Regarding "little blue miracle pills" and "the spiritual odyssey" that IBS affords: I hate to speak for others, Charles, but I don’t know a single IBS sufferer who does nothing other than wait for a "cure"… We have all explored every possible solution, anything that hinted at helping our situation because our "situation", our disease, our disorder, our suffering is horrible! I don’t know of anyone who has simply given in to the pain and discomfort and isolation etc that comes with our malady. Indeed, that is why we are on this newsgroup, to share, to explore and to SEARCH continually for answers. To believe that IBS or cancer or a broken leg is a "spiritual journey" without seeing it as a body dealing with illness or trauma is stupid. All of life is a spiritual journey, yes, I agree with that. But, that does not make having coffee in the morning a religious experience…. rather, our connection with our individuality, our holiness because of a loving, forgiving God etc, that makes all of life’s moments a religious journey. You do the "readers" a disservice if all you have to offer is that we should see our suffering as an opportunity for growth. Granted, it is an opportunity, but it is also a concrete PHYSICAL situation and that suffering is so intense at times, it overshadows any "spiritual" moments you may feel are imbedded in this chapter of life. To shame someone because they are seeking relief from their pain and misery and depression from IBS because they are not spending their energy on "knowing themselves" better, is the disservice, Charles. Here I am, having found that Caltrate (not a blue pill by the way) has resolved my symptoms… and yet, I’m here. Why then, Charles if I am only after a cure, would I still be in this forum? I don’t just "preach" Caltrate… because it doesn’t work for everyone. I am here because I found support and acceptance and suggestions of things to try that might help. I am here because HOPEFULLY, I can say something that will help someone else… There is no "blue pill" for some people… but our genuine concern and caring can be more powerful than a "blue pill". I dare say, if you suffered physically as most of us have, you would not be able to make such comments about us focussing on the "physical" side of IBS. Good Grief, man! IBS is a physical malady. There are indeed emotional and psychological ramifications, but it is not "in our heads". It is NOT a matter of our being wusses who whine at every twinge of gut pain. Truly, a man who is in physical pain cannot focus on the spiritual side of things effectively until his phsyical needs are addressed. Ever try to teach a child who is starving? Christ taught us to meet physical needs AND spiritual needs. A man cannot eat parables. Stop harrassing us because we HOPE for cures… Some days HOPE is all we have to keep insanity from the door. It would be so easy to give in to despair. IBS is incurable… it is horrible and IT is what has put our lives on hold, not US. Don’t preach about disservice to the "readers". We are family, united in our common suffering. When we support each other and share our pain and our joys, the only disservice comes from someone who can’t join in our suffering and therefore, can’t join in our joys when one of us finds relief. If you cannot help, Charles, then do NOT hinder. We have enough to bear. Laura W
Response:
I am really sorry to be getting this response. I know about the physical pain associated with IBS. I have had it since 1981, which is for about 20 years. It is my struggle to come to grips with this illness which has led me to explore myself in ways I probably would not have otherwise. However, I have taken your comments about smugness quite seriously, and will do some reflecting about it. I have obviously not been sensitive to the suffering of others, and I apologize. Your struggles deserve better. Regarding my parents paying for my rent… I actually live in a basement flat. I work diminished hours because IBS has taught me some implications related to job burnout. My mobility is affected by my illness. I can’t go on long trips, and I can’t live with the girl I love because my life isn’t normal. Anyway, why get into the limitations? I was trying to focus on the positive side, but failed miserably. I hope you all find peace with your problems. Those people who help others in this NG are doing everyone a great service. If you don’t mind, I would like to drop this thread. It has generated enough negativity. So why don’t we move on… Thanks, Charles Laura Wallace <lewsl…@home.com
wrote in message
news:uJ0O6.49418$I5.11013967@news1.rdc1.tn.home.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Regarding "little blue miracle pills" and "the spiritual odyssey" that IBS affords: I hate to speak for others, Charles, but I don’t know a single IBS
sufferer
who does nothing other than wait for a "cure"… We have all explored
every
possible solution, anything that hinted at helping our situation because
our
"situation", our disease, our disorder, our suffering is horrible! I
don’t
know of anyone who has simply given in to the pain and discomfort and isolation etc that comes with our malady. Indeed, that is why we are on this newsgroup, to share, to explore and to SEARCH continually for
answers.
To believe that IBS or cancer or a broken leg is a "spiritual journey" without seeing it as a body dealing with illness or trauma is stupid. All of life is a spiritual journey, yes, I agree with that. But, that does
not
make having coffee in the morning a religious experience…. rather, our connection with our individuality, our holiness because of a loving, forgiving God etc, that makes all of life’s moments a religious journey. You do the "readers" a disservice if all you have to offer is that we
should
see our suffering as an opportunity for growth. Granted, it is an opportunity, but it is also a concrete PHYSICAL situation and that
suffering
is so intense at times, it overshadows any "spiritual" moments you may
feel
are imbedded in this chapter of life. To shame someone because they are seeking relief from their pain and misery and depression from IBS because they are not spending their energy on "knowing themselves" better, is the disservice, Charles. Here I am, having found that Caltrate (not a blue pill by the way) has resolved my symptoms… and yet, I’m here. Why then, Charles if I am only after a cure, would I still be in this forum? I don’t just "preach" Caltrate… because it doesn’t work for everyone. I am here because I
found
support and acceptance and suggestions of things to try that might help.
I
am here because HOPEFULLY, I can say something that will help someone else… There is no "blue pill" for some people… but our genuine concern and caring can be more powerful than a "blue pill". I dare say, if you suffered physically as most of us have, you would not
be
able to make such comments about us focussing on the "physical" side of
IBS.
Good Grief, man! IBS is a physical malady. There are indeed emotional
and
psychological ramifications, but it is not "in our heads". It is NOT a matter of our being wusses who whine at every twinge of gut pain. Truly, a man who is in physical pain cannot focus on the spiritual side of things effectively until his phsyical needs are addressed. Ever try to teach a child who is starving? Christ taught us to meet physical needs AND spiritual needs. A man cannot eat parables. Stop harrassing us because we HOPE for cures… Some days HOPE is all we have to keep insanity from the door. It would be so easy to give in to despair. IBS is incurable… it is horrible and IT is what has put our lives on hold, not US. Don’t preach about disservice to the "readers".
We
are family, united in our common suffering. When we support each other
and
share our pain and our joys, the only disservice comes from someone who can’t join in our suffering and therefore, can’t join in our joys when one of us finds relief. If you cannot help, Charles, then do NOT hinder. We have enough to bear. Laura W
Response:
Laura, I read your very insightful post, and had to reply. My girlfriend is 5 years with IBS. I never knew about it until 3 weeks ago when she had an unusually severe episode at my mother’s house. I had only seen her collapse into vomitting, diahrrea, etc. twice before, and she told me it was food poisoning both times (we had been out to eat). This time, it was mom’s home cooking, and she was out for 3 hours after the initial purging, followed by severe tremors, high body temp variation, etc. We were readly to call an ambulance (she’s a nurse, BTW) and she confessed the history of this to me, much to my shock. She has had weekly episodes for about 2 years. She had been to doctors, has been told and has convinced herself that there is no cure. She has given in to the pain, and has lost hope of getting any relief. She has effectively hidden this from most of her friends, family and even the medical professionals she works with. After hearing her describe "IBS" (I had never even heard the term before), I started researching on the net and newsgroups, and here I am. I have found more support and information in 2 weeks than she has in 2 years. I am replying to point out that there are those (many?) who HAVE given up, lost their will to fight, and suffer terribly in silence. To forget them or deny their existence is a disservice to the fight for a cure. We must realize that for every victim with the resources to participate in an internet-based newsgroup discussion about IBS, there are a dozen who cannot, and become isolated from support. I believe you are a caring and loving person who gives much to relieve the suffering of others. Your participation in this discussion proves this out. My task is to follow your lead, and bring my friend back into the realm of hope for a cure for this disease. Nick C "Laura Wallace" <lewsl…@home.com
wrote in message
news:uJ0O6.49418$I5.11013967@news1.rdc1.tn.home.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Regarding "little blue miracle pills" and "the spiritual odyssey" that IBS affords: I hate to speak for others, Charles, but I don’t know a single IBS
sufferer
who does nothing other than wait for a "cure"… We have all explored
every
possible solution, anything that hinted at helping our situation because
our
"situation", our disease, our disorder, our suffering is horrible! I
don’t
know of anyone who has simply given in to the pain and discomfort and isolation etc that comes with our malady. Indeed, that is why we are on this newsgroup, to share, to explore and to SEARCH continually for
answers.
To believe that IBS or cancer or a broken leg is a "spiritual journey" without seeing it as a body dealing with illness or trauma is stupid. All of life is a spiritual journey, yes, I agree with that. But, that does
not
make having coffee in the morning a religious experience…. rather, our connection with our individuality, our holiness because of a loving, forgiving God etc, that makes all of life’s moments a religious journey. You do the "readers" a disservice if all you have to offer is that we
should
see our suffering as an opportunity for growth. Granted, it is an opportunity, but it is also a concrete PHYSICAL situation and that
suffering
is so intense at times, it overshadows any "spiritual" moments you may
feel
are imbedded in this chapter of life. To shame someone because they are seeking relief from their pain and misery and depression from IBS because they are not spending their energy on "knowing themselves" better, is the disservice, Charles. Here I am, having found that Caltrate (not a blue pill by the way) has resolved my symptoms… and yet, I’m here. Why then, Charles if I am only after a cure, would I still be in this forum? I don’t just "preach" Caltrate… because it doesn’t work for everyone. I am here because I
found
support and acceptance and suggestions of things to try that might help.
I
am here because HOPEFULLY, I can say something that will help someone else… There is no "blue pill" for some people… but our genuine concern and caring can be more powerful than a "blue pill". I dare say, if you suffered physically as most of us have, you would not
be
able to make such comments about us focussing on the "physical" side of
IBS.
Good Grief, man! IBS is a physical malady. There are indeed emotional
and
psychological ramifications, but it is not "in our heads". It is NOT a matter of our being wusses who whine at every twinge of gut pain. Truly, a man who is in physical pain cannot focus on the spiritual side of things effectively until his phsyical needs are addressed. Ever try to teach a child who is starving? Christ taught us to meet physical needs AND spiritual needs. A man cannot eat parables. Stop harrassing us because we HOPE for cures… Some days HOPE is all we have to keep insanity from the door. It would be so easy to give in to despair. IBS is incurable… it is horrible and IT is what has put our lives on hold, not US. Don’t preach about disservice to the "readers".
We
are family, united in our common suffering. When we support each other
and
share our pain and our joys, the only disservice comes from someone who can’t join in our suffering and therefore, can’t join in our joys when one of us finds relief. If you cannot help, Charles, then do NOT hinder. We have enough to bear. Laura W
Response: