Question:
I have had 2 sleep studies which determined mild apnea, resulting in a prescription for a CPAP. I bought my machine outright and use it religiously, but have NEVER again had the great feeling I did that morning after my second sleep study. The only benefit I seem to get from the use of the CPAP is that I no longer snore (and more no longer ’slobber’ on my pillow). More as a courtesy to my wife than anything else, I continue its use. I also had to buy a watch dog because I cannot hear as well at night with the machine running. However, I have recently (the past 6 moths or so) been having a runny nose, especially in the morning, and an apparent loss of my sense of smell (it seems I no longer need a bathroom air freshener, but my wife disagrees). I wrote to this list twice regarding this, but only received a single reply which suggested the use of a humidifier. I’m not sure if this will help, but I’m willing to try so that I can continue using CPAP for my wife’s sake. I don’t mind buying a humidifier for a trial, but not sure whether to get a heated or non-heated unit. Also, because I fired my doctor, I am unable to get a prescription, so will have to either buy from an individual or eBay. If anyone on this list has one available I would like to hear from them directly, off list. ron.carr…@att.net I would appreciate recommendation regarding the advantages/disadvantages of heated vs. non-heated before I buy. Thanks, Ron
Response:
I don’t mind buying a humidifier for a trial, but not sure whether to get
a
heated or non-heated unit. Also, because I fired my doctor, I am unable
to
get a prescription, so will have to either buy from an individual or eBay. If anyone on this list has one available I would like to hear from them directly, off list. ron.carr…@att.net
A heated humidifier may solve your problem. the constant irritation of pressurised air through your nose causes congestion and sometimes swelling……………….the heated humidifer helps avoid this problem. Note that you will also benefit from insulating your hose once you get the humidifier – especially if your bedroom is cold. A heated unit is nearly always much more beneficial than a passover (non-heated) one….if it’s not beyond your means, go for the heated one.
Response:
Ron wrote:
I don’t mind buying a humidifier for a trial, but not sure whether to get a heated or non-heated unit. Also, because I fired my doctor, I am unable to get a prescription, so will have to either buy from an individual or eBay. If anyone on this list has one available I would like to hear from them directly, off list. ron.carr…@att.net
If you are paying for it, go with the heated. If you don’t need the heat, you can turn it off and use it unheated, but if the cold humidifier doesn’t give enough moisture you will be back to buy a heated one. — Magesteff Freedom is hammered out on the anvil of discussion, dissent, and debate. -Hubert H. Humphrey (1911-1978), Speech, June 6, 1965, Syracuse University, N.Y
Response:
Ron <just-me@#home-sweet-home.com
wrote: I appreciate the information and tip regarding condensation, I’ll use it. FYI, I went online to the CPAPMAN.COM and he has a notice that humidifiers require a prescription. Good news if they don’t.
As I said, http://www.cpap-company.com/ did not require a prescription for the humidifier. I guess that since the humidifier for the RemStars won’t fit or work with any other machine, and if you have a RemStar, you got it with a prescription, you don’t need a separate one for the humidifier.
Been sleeping well with the humidifier. I have it set to the max and with the insulation on the hose, I don’t have much problem with condensation. Only found out there was some when I awoke and rolled over to turn on the light. When the exhaust port faced down, water came out, several drops. None in the nose, which is what counts! Several things to consider. Use steam distilled water in the humidifier to prevent deposits and because nothing will grow in it. Get some extra of the fine filters for the CPAP, the fine ones are not reusable, but are very inexpensive, only a couple of bucks each at the CPAP Company. Check the fine filter and change if needed monthly, (adjust interval as needed). The fine filter keeps out pollen and other fine stuff, which can help give your nose a rest from having to filter it out and will help if you have alergies or not. If the fine filter gets ’full’, it will restrict the intake of air to the CPAP and you may get reduced pressure, so do check it at least monthly. Also remember that apnea is a condition and CPAP is a treatment. This means it isn’t a ‘cure’. Treatment means it is an ongoing process. It will take time to get the full benefit, though you should see some results fairly quickly. It also means that your condition may vary depending on a number of factors and you will need to adjust the treatment over time. I know that I have to change the humidifer setting as the weather changes. With CPAP, think of it as a journey of discovery. I have had my CPAP for about 4 months now. I got it on December 31’st. I haven’t missed a night yet. The problems without having a heated humidifer at first were not fun at all and why I strongly reccomend getting the heated humidifier to people, even if they have to pay out of pocket. Compliance, (meaning using the CPAP, not just having it hold down papers on a table), depends heavily on ‘comfort level’, and a heated humidifer makes a huge difference. The heated humidifier is one of the few thigs you can control. If you read this newsgroup, you probably know that there are a lot of different masks. There are only a few that seem to get high marks from a lot of people. However there are others that may fit you better. This is part of what the Sleep Lab and DME should help with. I have a moustache and found the mask they gave me for the sleep test leaked through the moustache and I did not like the cold air leaking, it was noisy and uncomfortable. So I went with the nasal pillows for my CPAP setup. I asked for the Breeze as it was highly reccomended on this newsgroup by those that use the nasal pillows. Insurance only went for the less expensive ADAM Circuit. After I found out that I needed the next larger size pillows and got a set and got the ‘flexible hose’ which is a short length of pleated hose that goes from the angle adaptor over the head to the swivel joint, I found I like the ADAM Circuit. After insulating the hose all is well and I am sleeping better than I can remember for decades. I now can sleep on my back for the first time in longer than I can remember! Are there negatives to CPAP, yes. The inconvenience of having to attend to the machine, blowing out the water in the hose in the morning, cleaning the nasal pillows daily, putting more water in the humidifer chamber, putting Ayer Saline Gel in my nose each night before bed and putting on the CPAP before sleep. Is it worth it? YES!!! I’ve rambled on long enough, so all that is left is to wish you good luck and good times and pleasant and abundant sleep with the CPAP. Ross Bernheim As my mother said, "If at first you don’t succeed, suck eggs, they’re much softer!"
Response:
"Ron" <just-me@#home-sweet-home.com
wrote: I bought my machine outright and use it religiously, but have NEVER again had the great feeling I did that morning after my second sleep study.
Did you ever go back for re-titration? You may just need a little more pressure.
I don’t mind buying a humidifier for a trial, but not sure whether to get a heated or non-heated unit. Also, because I fired my doctor, I am unable to get a prescription, so will have to either buy from an individual or eBay.
I’d certainly look at a heated unit, but you might be ok with a good passive unit, like the Respironics Oasis, since you’ve been doing fairly well without any humidification. I believe that any doctor can write the prescription, it doesn’t have to come from a sleep specialist. Tom
Response:
Ron <just-me@#home-sweet-home.com
wrote: I don’t mind buying a humidifier for a trial, but not sure whether to get a heated or non-heated unit. Also, because I fired my doctor, I am unable to get a prescription, so will have to either buy from an individual or eBay. If anyone on this list has one available I would like to hear from them directly, off list. ron.carr…@att.net
The humidifier is not a prescription item. I was able to walk into a local DME whom I had never seen before and purchace a heated humidifer for my CPAP off the shelf. This is the web address for the company where I got the humidifer; http://www.cpap-company.com/ the are very friendly and helpful people and seem to have some good deals. Also check out http://www.cpapman.com/ a very highly reccomended source by those in this news group.
I would appreciate recommendation regarding the advantages/disadvantages of heated vs. non-heated before I buy.
Definitely go heated and buy or sew an insulating cover for the hose to allow more heat and humidity without condensation problems and water in the nose. Humidity is really relative humidity and the warmer the air, the more humidity it can hold. You want a lot of humidity or at least the ability to get a lot if you want or need it. Insulate the hose as it is cooler and causes condensation unless insulated. Ross Bernheim
Response:
Thanks for your help, Ross. I appreciate the information and tip regarding condensation, I’ll use it. FYI, I went online to the CPAPMAN.COM and he has a notice that humidifiers require a prescription. Good news if they don’t. Good night, Ron "Ross Bernheim" <ross…@mindspring.com
wrote in message
news:1fb9jgz.uz6l1py31fleN%rossber@mindspring.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Ron <just-me@#home-sweet-home.com wrote: I don’t mind buying a humidifier for a trial, but not sure whether to
get a
heated or non-heated unit. Also, because I fired my doctor, I am unable
to
get a prescription, so will have to either buy from an individual or
eBay.
If anyone on this list has one available I would like to hear from them directly, off list. ron.carr…@att.net The humidifier is not a prescription item. I was able to walk into a local DME whom I had never seen before and purchace a heated humidifer for my CPAP off the shelf. This is the web address for the company where I got the humidifer; http://www.cpap-company.com/ the are very friendly and helpful people and seem to have some good deals. Also check out http://www.cpapman.com/ a very highly reccomended source by those in this news group. I would appreciate recommendation regarding the advantages/disadvantages
of
heated vs. non-heated before I buy. Definitely go heated and buy or sew an insulating cover for the hose to allow more heat and humidity without condensation problems and water in the nose. Humidity is really relative humidity and the warmer the air, the more humidity it can hold. You want a lot of humidity or at least the ability to get a lot if you want or need it. Insulate the hose as it is cooler and causes condensation unless insulated. Ross Bernheim
Response:
Not all passive humidifiers are equal. The OASIS puts a *lot* more water into the air than others. If the pressure is low (maybe 10-12cm or less?) the OASIS might do just fine. OASIS are available on ebay frequently and some times go for < $50. I am at 18cm and lived with an OASIS for 3 yrs before buying a Humidaire on ebay. I still use the OASIS as my travel humidifier. Unless the room is very cold and dry it suffices. And you can make an OASIS put out even more water by wrapping it in a small heating pad. With a heating pad, I can get rainout from the OASIS even with insulated tubing. That tells me the OASIS is putting a lot of water into the air. The amount of water the unheated OASIS uses per night at 18cm CPAP is about 2/3 of what the Humidaire does at a setting of 5.5 regards, eric pearson db2e…@nospammindspring.com On Fri, 26 Apr 2002 21:55:43 -0400, "S. J. Muller" <mages…@juno.com
wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Ron wrote: I don’t mind buying a humidifier for a trial, but not sure whether to get a heated or non-heated unit. Also, because I fired my doctor, I am unable to get a prescription, so will have to either buy from an individual or eBay. If anyone on this list has one available I would like to hear from them directly, off list. ron.carr…@att.net If you are paying for it, go with the heated. If you don’t need the heat, you can turn it off and use it unheated, but if the cold humidifier doesn’t give enough moisture you will be back to buy a heated one.
Response:
"gaj" <shalomnum…@attbi.com
wrote in message
news:3F048A7C.27FAAE78@attbi.com…
I wish your doctor would explain why demineralized water is better than distilled water. Chemically, I believe that distilled water is as close to pure water that you can get, also that it is totally sterilized during distillation, which is not the case for demineralized water. I use distilled because it does not leave any residue upon evaporation, and I clean it out every two or three months. Tap water should be fine, except for the heavy mineral deposits over time. You can use vinegar to remove them periodically. — Glenn
For a number of reasons demineralized (or deionized) water tends to have a higher purity in terms of salts. But it’s not the salts that are concerning people. It’s the bugs. Distilled should be better for bugs. Paul R
Response:
Maybe your tap water…. but not mine. Too many possible bacterial problems there, plus the smell of chlorination.
Good point. I drink Lake Erie water. Lake Erie water is pretty soft and doesn’t have a high sulfide load. Chlorination is fairly light so it doesn’t smell (to me, anyway) like a bleach bottle or a swimming pool. Paul R
Response:
"eric" <db2e…@nospammindspring.com
wrote in message
news:ba89gv416sct82fvasd7v6122uldst2r62@4ax.com…
It is a problem. How big a problem depends upon how ‘hard’ your water is and your degree of toleratoin of the humidifier cleaning process. If you use distilled water, the humidifier needs cleaning less frequently. Period. regards, eric pearson
Agreed! I’m not sure that daily, weekly, monthly cleaning is really needed. But not doing it creeps me out, so I do it. Paul R
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Paul R wrote:
"eric" <db2e…@nospammindspring.com wrote in message news:ba89gv416sct82fvasd7v6122uldst2r62@4ax.com… It is a problem. How big a problem depends upon how ‘hard’ your water is and your degree of toleratoin of the humidifier cleaning process. If you use distilled water, the humidifier needs cleaning less frequently. Period. regards, eric pearson Agreed! I’m not sure that daily, weekly, monthly cleaning is really needed. But not doing it creeps me out, so I do it.
Never heard of a better reason than that!!!
Response:
How can you tell if you should be using a cold air humidfer or a hot air humidifer? I have a humidifer that uses room temp. water and I hear a lot about the heated humidifer and I want to ask my doctor about which one is best but I want to know something about the difference before doing so thank you joe from baltimore
Response:
Reading all with interest in this thread…. De-mineralised – due to no buildup…. No tapwater due to potential bugs (and minerals). In Different Parts of Australia, the quality of the tapwater varies greatly, I have lived in several parts, some of which I would not drink the tapwater! In my case, my sleep doc/DME recommended de-mineralised water due to the tapwater in this part of the country being rather heavy, compared to other parts of the country. (DME recommendation was probably also due to the fact that at first I was only renting the machine, and if I did return it, they wanted it to be Very easy to clean….) A few Years ago, there was a nasty scare in Sydney WRT to tapwater, It did in fact get a nasty bug and everyone was told to boil it. The source of the contamination was the pipes it was being delivered in. I appreciate comments being made here about how much/little people clean various parts of their xPAP and for what reasons. I probably should have said a little more…. I personally put into the humidifier chamber just enough water, so it is all gone by morning – trial and error over several days. rarely throw out any water. I, like a lot of other people, do not wash everything out, the exception being my interface (due to excessive oily skin) but leave it to dry in the room each day. We can all see from comments posted, there is a lot of mis-information and myths, but I think someone else best summed it up – Do whatever you feel comfortable doing. It that is sterilising everything daily – do it. If it means washing it if it looks dirty – do it. If it means chucking it out when it wears out with never having cleaned it ……. Norm, In relation to "diplomated sleep doc" I am not aware of any such thing in Aus… Other than any specialist having studied in their field…. You are right, we may all speak the English language, but English probably has more "regional Dialects" than any other language in the world, but this is another debate I am sure!!!!! ( WRT Frankie and CA- ) From looking at the posts, there are only a handful of posters from Aus here and I personally do not say anything unless I feel can make a worthwhile contribution or offer a different perspective. If I know nothing about a subject I would pose a Question….. Bob in Aus "NormC" <no…@socal.rr.com
wrote in message
news:3F04BF24.8090204@socal.rr.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Forgot the most important factor: My respiratory health has been much better since I’ve been on cpap. And I’m not the only one to post this. NormC wrote: Quick wrote: Norm, [I won't cut anything from the post since I notice you never do that but I've extracted the sections I wanted to comment on and brought them to the top. Original post is below in its entirety.] As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (4 years). In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness. I agree that distilled water will not cause any illness by itself and its obvious that you are inhaling the same air you breath when awake. Is there anything about distilled water that would prevent it from being a good medium for "incubating" biological organisms? IMHO, yes, by definition of what distilled water is. Although it’s in the archives, I will try to find the link that was posted by someone a couple years ago and satisfied me and a number of others who had been around here for longer than me. Based on your ‘probabilistic’ comment in the ‘lightning’ thread, I’m sure you will understand that I can’t say there is a zero probablility of any kind of incubation. But, like you, I CAN say that, although 0, it is very, very small. Especially heated for periods of time and at room tempurature the rest of the
time.
Certainly the air you breath contains various agents in varying concentrations. While those things may be harmless in the air you breath I would think there is some small chance that some may become harmful if concentrated or allowed to "grow" or multiply in what amounts to a petri dish? (I could imagine this may be the fallacy in my thinking) I cleaned my system the first few months, per the handbook, until my cognition improved to the point that I could once again think clearly. Then I realized that it didn’t make any sense (to me) and even the ratio of vinegar to water was not consistent from one manual to another or from one RT to another. All of it was posted here. See it in the archives. I haven’t washed any part of my system for over two years. And that’s on top of having a compromised immune system and bronchial asthma. I do one thing that I’m not aware of anyone else doing: Whe first day I started on cpap I dropped and broke one of the two humidifier reservoirs that came with the blower. I wanted to have a spare, but they came in pairs. So, I have three. I get a little uneasy when I see moisture accumulating at the top of the reservoir (don’t ask me why, because I haven’t the faintest idea), so I remove one when I don’t like the way it looks and replace it with another, letting the first completely dry until the same thing happens to the second one. The only other thing I do is pull the tube/hose off the humidifier every single morning, to let what little moisture accumulates at that end, dry. Oh, yes, I wash my face every night. I run my tube/hose from one side to the other, above my head, on the pillow. I have never had rainout, not even durng the rainy season. I use distilled water primarily for the lack of deposits since I am not worried about my tap water (I wouldn’t be drinking it, cooking with it, or bathing in steamy showers with it otherwise). For me, 20-30 minutes in a steamy shower, where I live, results in more respiratory distress than 8 1/2 hours on my CPAP. For this reason (mistaken?) I dump the remains in my humidifier each morning — the RemStar humidifier chamber is easily removed, dumped, disassembled (remove bottom) and left to dry. Assuming this is possible I suppose that it may take days or weeks for anything harmful to "grow" or achieve harmful concentrations and constantly refilling the humidifier might have the effect of running water eliminating that. My daily routine involves: Remove hose from mask and humidifier and leave coiled on shelf to dry. Remove humidifier, dump, disassemble and leave on shelf to dry. Remove pillows from interface, wash with anti-bacterial hand soap, and leave on shelf to dry with the other part (mainly to remove skin oils, etc). Every couple of weeks or at most monthly I soak all the above and the
air
filter with dish soap in the kitchen sink. I figure letting everything dry puts you on par with the air you
breath. > > Sounds like a good reson for my assuring that moisture doesn’t accumlate > > at the top of my reservoir or in the beginning of the tube/hose. > > HTH > >> -Quick > >> "NormC" <no…@socal.rr.com
wrote in message
> >> news:3F049151.903@socal.rr.com… > >>> Bob – It becomes more clear (to me), every day, that even though > >>> we all speak English in the US, Canada, UK, and Australia, what > >>> the doctors tell us about sleep disorders, and the treatment we > >>> receive, in each country is noticeably different. > >>> Take Frankie, for example, in the UK. She appears to have > >>> central apnea and the NHS just lets her drop by the wayside?!?!? > >>> Any idea of what they do about CA in Australia (or Canada)? > >>> Noone from Australia (or Canada) has responded to her posts. > >>> Maybe the a.lange & sohne replica watches word ‘distilled’ and ‘demineralized’ mean different > >>> things in Australia than the US. But, I doubt it. > >>> IMHO you received a lot of questionable information from your > >>> sleep doctor. Does he have any kind of certification to be a > >>> sleep doc, or don’t they have that sort of thing in Australia? > >>> As any kind of doctor, he should know the difference between > >>> distilled water and demineralzed water, as indicated by Lee. So a > >>> real (good) sleep doc, should know it. > >>> IIRC, Legionaires disease was first discovered in the US, at an > >>> American Legion Convention in a particular hotel. IIRC it was > >>> associated with their refrigerated air conditioning system. > >>> I was not aware of one person giving another person Legionaires > >>> disease. However, it has occurred more than once in the US in > >>> large groups. > >>> Every post I’ve ever read here indicated that their User Manual > >>> indicated distilled water. Mine does. What does your manual say? > >>> IMHO, the use of demineralized water would be totally > >>> inconsistent with trying to avoid any kind of ‘disease’. And > >>> throwing away any unused distilled water is a waste of money. > >>> As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, > >>> there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re > >>> inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is > >>> filtered by the blower filter. The
… read more »
Response:
Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. So this is what confused me. From Bob’s post his doctor told him that de-mineralised water would have less chance of being or getting biologically contaminated. Was it a typo?
I’m wondering if there was a communication and either the doc said, or the OP heard distilled water instead of mineral water…….it would make more sense — Beth in Australia =================== FAQ for alt.support.sleep-disorder can be found here http://talhost.net/sleep this site is a work in progress – feel free to submit info/articles Remove my name to reply
Response:
Any chance of this happening with a unclean air conditioner? I have not used a filter in mine for a couple of years because I lost it, by reading this I think it may be time to order one! thanks. Don "Bob in Aus" <bREMOVEo…@norcom.net.au.remove.me
wrote in message
news:3f0425b3$0$59955$c30e37c6@lon-reader.news.telstra.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
I was a bit on the lazy side as well until it was put into terms that I
now
understand that it is not laziness but a necessity. I recently had a follow-up with my sleep doc and he explained to me
why….
Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. Empty out any remaining water in the humidifier on a daily basis. The reason he gave was simply de-mineralised water will harbour the least amount of bacteria, and will not leave any residue in the chamber (well,
not
any, but the least amount) Chuck out the remaining every morning as the Legionella (sp?) virus can
kill
you! Here in Australia, we hear of several (up to 10) per year cases of legionnaires disease, basically a virus that kills people. The source is usually traced to contaminated water in cooling systems in large office buildings, shopping centres or other public buildings. I think that by chucking out a bit of water each day, rather than
breathing > in a potential source for (often Fatal) infection for 7 1/2 hours a day a > simple and worthwhile procedure. > Put in these terms, that is a pretty good incentive for me to keep my > humidifier clean! > Bob in Aus > "Tchmuzk" <tchm…@surfbest.net
wrote in message
> news:be143p$og8$1@news.chatlink.com… > > I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA > > told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am,
I never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced hot air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
Hello joe, I noticed no one has answered your question yet so I’ll give it a whirl. I have the option on my F&P (NADA) to use no humidity, cold passove,r and heated humidity. I like cold passover, but the heated humidity works better for me. The cold passover is good, but it leaves me with a little dryness in the nose. I have more congestion with the cold passover. A friend of mine who is also a hoover head does not have humidity and is VERY congested upon waking. It takes a while to clear that out in the morning if you know what I mean. I was titrated without humidity. Woke up with dryness and soreness inside the throat and nose. I first started using CPAP with the highest heat setting on the machine. I was told to do this to get used to CPAP quicker. It worked. I have lowered it to about a third of what I started out at and I’m fine. I highly recommend the heated humidity if you can get it! HTH Marco Polo On Thu, 3 Jul 2003 22:05:20 -0400 (EDT), peacefulf…@webtv.net (joe) wrote:
How can you tell if you should be using a cold air humidfer or a hot air humidifer? I have a humidifer that uses room temp. water and I hear a lot about the heated humidifer and I want to ask my doctor about which one is best but I want to know something about the difference before doing so thank you joe from baltimore
"Never, never doubt what nobody is really sure about!" Marco Polo
Response:
I’m not as enthusiastic as Anna is below, but I DO clean out everything at some point. The mask cushion–every day. Mask shell, hose, and water chamber = once a week and I switch out the water chamber with the spare that I’ve already cleaned (no vinegar though). Every month, I clean the CPAP unit and check the air filter–change it if necessary. I only use Ivory Liquid dishwashing detergent (NADA) in warm water. I guess how much you clean depends on how susceptible you are to infection. Prior to my septoplasty in 2001, I would get sinus infections almost at the drop of a hat. After surgery, they are less frequent, and if I play it right, I can go a couple of years without infection. I also irrigate with .9% saline solution at least every other day and use Ponaris oil. I dump the heated distilled water right back into the gallon jug of distilled water I buy from Wal-Mart (NADA). The room is cool enough that bacteria don’t thrive. Now a discussion like this begs the question: has anyone ever sneezed while wearing their mask? Marco Polo On Thu, 03 Jul 2003 22:43:40 -0700, Anna LeBlanc <lebla…@qwest.net
wrote: >Almost every day I dump, rinse, wash in sudsy water, rinse, hang to dry, and >sometimes reassemble the hose part to my RemStar and blow it to dry while I >eat breakfast. I’m way at the fastidious end of the scale around here. <g
>But I don’t know how to remove the bottom of the RemStar humidifier chamber! >Does it slide off one end? I don’t see any hinges, how do you do it? >Thanks >Anna
"Never, never doubt what nobody is really sure about!" Marco Polo
Response:
in article 1057269089.462083@sj-nntpcache-3, Quick at dhorw…@NOSPAMcisco.com wrote on 7/3/2003 2:50 PM: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
For this reason (mistaken?) I dump the remains in my humidifier each morning — the RemStar humidifier chamber is easily removed, dumped, disassembled (remove bottom) and left to dry. Assuming this is possible I suppose that it may take days or weeks for anything harmful to "grow" or achieve harmful concentrations and constantly refilling the humidifier might have the effect of running water eliminating that. My daily routine involves: Remove hose from mask and humidifier and leave coiled on shelf to dry. Remove humidifier, dump, disassemble and leave on shelf to dry. Remove pillows from interface, wash with anti-bacterial hand soap, and leave on shelf to dry with the other part (mainly to remove skin oils, etc). Every couple of weeks or at most monthly I soak all the above and the air filter with dish soap in the kitchen sink. I figure letting everything dry puts you on par with the air you breath. -Quick
Quick, Almost every day I dump, rinse, wash in sudsy water, rinse, hang to dry, and sometimes reassemble the hose part to my RemStar and blow it to dry while I eat breakfast. I’m way at the fastidious end of the scale around here. <g
But I don’t know how to remove the bottom of the RemStar humidifier chamber! Does it slide off one end? I don’t see any hinges, how do you do it? Thanks Anna
Response:
"Quick" <dhorw…@NOSPAMcisco.com
wrote in message
news:1057263453.408921@sj-nntpcache-5… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
"Lee Babcock" <leebabc…@pathcom.com wrote Quick wrote: "Bob in Aus" <bREMOVEo…@norcom.net.au.remove.me wrote Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. I always thought distilled water *was* de-mineralised? Can somebody elaborate on the differences? I suppose there is a difference in the process to produce it? -Quick Distilled water is de-mineralized among other things, but de-mineralized water is water that was passed through a mechanical filter to remove the minerals. The heat of the distillation process also kills bacteria and the evaporation of the condesation of the vapour leaves you with just water. Regards Lee in Toronto So this is what confused me. From Bob’s post his doctor told him that de-mineralised water would have less chance of being or getting biologically contaminated. Was it a typo? -Quick
Demineralizing water is a two step process. Industrially this is usually done in two separate vessels, but the steps can be combined if you’re willing to accept lower efficiency for greater convenience. The first step takes out metal ions like Calcium and Sodium and replaces them with Hydrogen (acid). The second step takes out the anions like sulfate, chloride, etc. replacing them with Hydroxyl (caustic). The Hydrogen and Hydroxyl combine simply producing more water. The result is that you have no (none, zilch) salts left. That’s really great if you’re dealing with a soap that will crap out (precipitate) in the presence of salts. But the deionizer doesn’t do anything about biologics like bacteria, or organics like gasoline, phenol or methyl-ethyl bad stuff. Distilled water will get rid of anything that evaporates at a higher temperature than water, but not lower unless a fractionating column is used like in a refinery (do the maker of distilled water use these? Since most evil stuff in water is higher boiling than water, stills produce good water. Having said all of that, I use tap water. Tap water is chlorinated, so any bugs should be dead. Unless you’re dealing with a real fly-by-night water company, or have a non-certified well, the chemical load should be acceptable. And the water may be a whole lot cleaner than the bottled water (depending on the care of the bottler). I certainly agree with dump the water daily and rince the humidifier out. Then weekly take the thing apart if you can and give it a good cleaning. Note: If your tap water is hard, then you must use distilled water. Or you’ll build up a crust in the humidifier. Paul R
Response:
Forgot the most important factor: My respiratory health has been much better since I’ve been on cpap. And I’m not the only one to post this. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -NormC wrote:
Quick wrote: Norm, [I won't cut anything from the post since I notice you never do that but I've extracted the sections I wanted to comment on and brought them to the top. Original post is below in its entirety.] As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (4 years). In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness. I agree that distilled water will not cause any illness by itself and its obvious that you are inhaling the same air you breath when awake. Is there anything about distilled water that would prevent it from being a good medium for "incubating" biological organisms? IMHO, yes, by definition of what distilled water is. Although it’s in the archives, I will try to find the link that was posted by someone a couple years ago and satisfied me and a number of others who had been around here for longer than me. Based on your ‘probabilistic’ comment in the ‘lightning’ thread, I’m sure you will understand that I can’t say there is a zero probablility of any kind of incubation. But, like you, I CAN say that, although 0, it is very, very small. Especially heated for periods of time and at room tempurature the rest of the time. Certainly the air you breath contains various agents in varying concentrations. While those things may be harmless in the air you breath I would think there is some small chance that some may become harmful if concentrated or allowed to "grow" or multiply in what amounts to a petri dish? (I could imagine this may be the fallacy in my thinking) I cleaned my system the first few months, per the handbook, until my cognition improved to the point that I could once again think clearly. Then I realized that it didn’t make any sense (to me) and even the ratio of vinegar to water was not consistent from one manual to another or from one RT to another. All of it was posted here. See it in the archives. I haven’t washed any part of my system for over two years. And that’s on top of having a compromised immune system and bronchial asthma. I do one thing that I’m not aware of anyone else doing: Whe first day I started on cpap I dropped and broke one of the two humidifier reservoirs that came with the blower. I wanted to have a spare, but they came in pairs. So, I have three. I get a little uneasy when I see moisture accumulating at the top of the reservoir (don’t ask me why, because I haven’t the faintest idea), so I remove one when I don’t like the way it looks and replace it with another, letting the first completely dry until the same thing happens to the second one. The only other thing I do is pull the tube/hose off the humidifier every single morning, to let what little moisture accumulates at that end, dry. Oh, yes, I wash my face every night. I run my tube/hose from one side to the other, above my head, on the pillow. I have never had rainout, not even durng the rainy season. I use distilled water primarily for the lack of deposits since I am not worried about my tap water (I wouldn’t be drinking it, cooking with it, or bathing in steamy showers with it otherwise). For me, 20-30 minutes in a steamy shower, where I live, results in more respiratory distress than 8 1/2 hours on my CPAP. For this reason (mistaken?) I dump the remains in my humidifier each morning — the RemStar humidifier chamber is easily removed, dumped, disassembled (remove bottom) and left to dry. Assuming this is possible I suppose that it may take days or weeks for anything harmful to "grow" or achieve harmful concentrations and constantly refilling the humidifier might have the effect of running water eliminating that. My daily routine involves: Remove hose from mask and humidifier and leave coiled on shelf to dry. Remove humidifier, dump, disassemble and leave on shelf to dry. Remove pillows from interface, wash with anti-bacterial hand soap, and leave on shelf to dry with the other part (mainly to remove skin oils, etc). Every couple of weeks or at most monthly I soak all the above and the air filter with dish soap in the kitchen sink. I figure letting everything dry puts you on par with the air you breath. Sounds like a good reson for my assuring that moisture doesn’t accumlate at the top of calibre 16 replica my reservoir or in the beginning of the tube/hose. HTH -Quick "NormC" <no…@socal.rr.com wrote in message news:3F049151.903@socal.rr.com… Bob – It becomes more clear (to me), every day, that even though we all speak English in the US, Canada, UK, and Australia, what the doctors tell us about sleep disorders, and the treatment we receive, in each country is noticeably different. Take Frankie, for example, in the UK. She appears to have central apnea and the NHS just lets her drop by the wayside?!?!? Any idea of what they do about CA in Australia (or Canada)? Noone from Australia (or Canada) has responded to her posts. Maybe the word ‘distilled’ and ‘demineralized’ mean different things in Australia than the US. But, I doubt it. IMHO you received a lot of questionable information from your sleep doctor. Does he have any kind of certification to be a sleep doc, or don’t they have that sort of thing in Australia? As any kind of doctor, he should know the difference between distilled water and demineralzed water, as indicated by Lee. So a real (good) sleep doc, should know it. IIRC, Legionaires disease was first discovered in the US, at an American Legion Convention in a particular hotel. IIRC it was associated with their refrigerated air conditioning system. I was not aware of one person giving another person Legionaires disease. However, it has occurred more than once in the US in large groups. Every post I’ve ever read here indicated that their User Manual indicated distilled water. Mine does. What does your manual say? IMHO, the use of demineralized water would be totally inconsistent with trying to avoid any kind of ‘disease’. And throwing away any unused distilled water is a waste of money. As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (4 years). In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness. The bottom line is to do what you feel is appropriate for your well being (both physical and psychological). Bob in Aus wrote: I was a bit on the lazy side as well until it was put into terms that I now understand that it is not laziness but a necessity. I recently had a follow-up with my sleep doc and he explained to me why…. Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. Empty out any remaining water in the humidifier on a daily basis. The reason he gave was simply de-mineralised water will harbour the least amount of bacteria, and will not leave any residue in the chamber (well, not any, but the least amount) Chuck out the remaining every morning as the Legionella (sp?) virus can kill you! Here in Australia, we hear of several (up to 10) per year cases of legionnaires disease, basically a virus that kills people. The source is usually traced to contaminated water in cooling systems in large office buildings, shopping centres or other public buildings. I think that by chucking out a bit of water each day, rather than breathing in a potential source for (often Fatal) infection for 7 1/2 hours a day a simple and worthwhile procedure. Put in these terms, that is a pretty good incentive for me to keep my humidifier clean! Bob in Aus "Tchmuzk" <tchm…@surfbest.net wrote in message news:be143p$og8$1@news.chatlink.com… I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am, I never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced hot air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Quick wrote:
Norm, [I won't cut anything from the post since I notice you never do that but I've extracted the sections I wanted to comment on and brought them to the top. Original post is below in its entirety.] As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (4 years). In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness. I agree that distilled water will not cause any illness by itself and its obvious that you are inhaling the same air you breath when awake. Is there anything about distilled water that would prevent it from being a good medium for "incubating" biological organisms?
IMHO, yes, by definition of what distilled water is. Although it’s in the archives, I will try to find the link that was posted by someone a couple years ago and satisfied me and a number of others who had been around here for longer than me. Based on your ‘probabilistic’ comment in the ‘lightning’ thread, I’m sure you will understand that I can’t say there is a zero probablility of any kind of incubation. But, like you, I CAN say that, although
0, it is very, very small. Especially heated for periods of time and at room tempurature the rest of the time. Certainly the air you breath contains various agents in varying concentrations. While those things may be harmless in the air you breath I would think there is some small chance that some may become harmful if concentrated or allowed to "grow" or multiply in what amounts to a petri dish? (I could imagine this may be the fallacy in my thinking)
I cleaned my system the first few months, per the handbook, until my cognition improved to the point that I could once again think clearly. Then I realized that it didn’t make any sense (to me) and even the ratio of vinegar to water was not consistent from one manual to another or from one RT to another. All of it was posted here. See it in the archives. I haven’t washed any part of my system for over two years. And that’s on top of having a compromised immune system and bronchial asthma. I do one thing that I’m not aware of anyone else doing: Whe first day I started on cpap I dropped and broke one of the two humidifier reservoirs that came with the blower. I wanted to have a spare, but they came in pairs. So, I have three. I get a little uneasy when I see moisture accumulating at the top of the reservoir (don’t ask me why, because I haven’t the faintest idea), so I remove one when I don’t like the way it looks and replace it with another, letting the first completely dry until the same thing happens to the second one. The only other thing I do is pull the tube/hose off the humidifier every single morning, to let what little moisture accumulates at that end, dry. Oh, yes, I wash my face every night. I run my tube/hose from one side to the Knowledge other, above my head, on the pillow. I have never had rainout, not even durng the rainy season.
I use distilled water primarily for the lack of deposits since I am not worried about my tap water (I wouldn’t be drinking it, cooking with it, or bathing in steamy showers with it otherwise).
For me, 20-30 minutes in a steamy shower, where I live, results in more respiratory distress than 8 1/2 hours on my CPAP. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
For this reason (mistaken?) I dump the remains in my humidifier each morning — the RemStar humidifier chamber is easily removed, dumped, disassembled (remove bottom) and left to dry. Assuming this is possible I suppose that it may take days or weeks for anything harmful to "grow" or achieve harmful concentrations and constantly refilling the humidifier might have the effect of running water eliminating that. My daily routine involves: Remove hose from mask and humidifier and leave coiled on shelf to dry. Remove humidifier, dump, disassemble and leave on shelf to dry. Remove pillows from interface, wash with anti-bacterial hand soap, and leave on shelf to dry with the other part (mainly to remove skin oils, etc). Every couple of weeks or at most monthly I soak all the above and the air filter with dish soap in the kitchen sink. I figure letting everything dry puts you on par with the air you breath.
Sounds like a good reson for my assuring that moisture doesn’t accumlate at the top of my reservoir or in the beginning of the tube/hose. HTH – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
-Quick "NormC" <no…@socal.rr.com wrote in message news:3F049151.903@socal.rr.com… Bob – It becomes more clear (to me), every day, that even though we all speak English in the US, Canada, UK, and Australia, what the doctors tell us about sleep disorders, and the treatment we receive, in each country is noticeably different. Take Frankie, for example, in the UK. She appears to have central apnea and the NHS just lets her drop by the wayside?!?!? Any idea of what they do about CA in Australia (or Canada)? Noone from Australia (or Canada) has responded to her posts. Maybe the word ‘distilled’ and ‘demineralized’ mean different things in Australia than the US. But, I doubt it. IMHO you received a lot of questionable information from your sleep doctor. Does he have any kind of certification to be a sleep doc, or don’t they have that sort of thing in Australia? As any kind of doctor, he should know the difference between distilled water and demineralzed water, as indicated by Lee. So a real (good) sleep doc, should know it. IIRC, Legionaires disease was first discovered in the US, at an American Legion Convention in a particular hotel. IIRC it was associated with their refrigerated air conditioning system. I was not aware of one person giving another person Legionaires disease. However, it has occurred more than once in the US in large groups. Every post I’ve ever read here indicated that their User Manual indicated distilled water. Mine does. What does your manual say? IMHO, the use of demineralized water would be totally inconsistent with trying to avoid any kind of ‘disease’. And throwing away any unused distilled water is a waste of money. As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (4 years). In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness. The bottom line is to do what you feel is appropriate for your well being (both physical and psychological). Bob in Aus wrote: I was a bit on the lazy side as well until it was put into terms that I now understand that it is not laziness but a necessity. I recently had a follow-up with my sleep doc and he explained to me why…. Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. Empty out any remaining water in the humidifier on a daily basis. The reason he gave was simply de-mineralised water will harbour the least amount of bacteria, and will not leave any residue in the chamber (well, not any, but the least amount) Chuck out the remaining every morning as the Legionella (sp?) virus can kill you! Here in Australia, we hear of several (up to 10) per year cases of legionnaires disease, basically a virus that kills people. The source is usually traced to contaminated water in cooling systems in large office buildings, shopping centres or other public buildings. I think that by chucking out a bit of water each day, rather than breathing in a potential source for (often Fatal) infection for 7 1/2 hours a day a simple and worthwhile procedure. Put in these terms, that is a pretty good incentive for me to keep my humidifier clean! Bob in Aus "Tchmuzk" <tchm…@surfbest.net wrote in message news:be143p$og8$1@news.chatlink.com… I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am, I never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced hot air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
gaj wrote:
I wish your doctor would explain why demineralized water is better than distilled water. Chemically, I believe that distilled water is as close to pure water that you can get, also that it is totally sterilized during distillation, which is not the case for demineralized water. I use distilled because it does not leave any residue upon evaporation, and I clean it out every two or three months.
What do you clean out of it? Tap water should be fine, Maybe your tap water…. but not mine. Too many possible bacterial problems there, plus the smell of chlorination. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
except for the heavy mineral deposits over time. You can use vinegar to remove them periodically.
Response:
It is a problem. How big a problem depends upon how ‘hard’ your water is and your degree of toleratoin of the humidifier cleaning process. If you use distilled water, the humidifier needs cleaning less frequently. Period. regards, eric pearson db2e…@nospammindspring.com On Thu, 3 Jul 2003 07:29:53 -0400, "Tchmuzk" <tchm…@surfbest.net
wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am, I never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced hot air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
Norm, [I won't cut anything from the post since I notice you never do that but I've extracted the sections I wanted to comment on and brought them to the top. Original post is below in its entirety.]
As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (4 years). In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness.
I agree that distilled water will not cause any illness by itself and its obvious that you are inhaling the same air you breath when awake. Is there anything about distilled water that would prevent it from being a good medium for "incubating" biological organisms? Especially heated for periods of time and at room tempurature the rest of the time. Certainly the air you breath contains various agents in varying concentrations. While those things may be harmless in the air you breath I would think there is some small chance that some may become harmful if concentrated or allowed to "grow" or multiply in what amounts to a petri dish? (I could imagine this may be the fallacy in my thinking) I use distilled water primarily for the lack of deposits since I am not worried about my tap water (I wouldn’t be drinking it, cooking with it, or bathing in steamy showers with it otherwise). For this reason (mistaken?) I dump the remains in my humidifier each morning — the RemStar humidifier chamber is easily removed, dumped, disassembled (remove bottom) and left to dry. Assuming this is possible I suppose that it may take days or weeks for anything harmful to "grow" or achieve harmful concentrations and constantly refilling the humidifier might have the effect of running water eliminating that. My daily routine involves: Remove hose from mask and humidifier and leave coiled on shelf to dry. Remove humidifier, dump, disassemble and leave on shelf to dry. Remove pillows from interface, wash with anti-bacterial hand soap, and leave on shelf to dry with the other part (mainly to remove skin oils, etc). Every couple of weeks or at most monthly I soak all the above and the air filter with dish soap in the kitchen sink. I figure letting everything dry puts you on par with the air you breath. -Quick "NormC" <no…@socal.rr.com
wrote in message
news:3F049151.903@socal.rr.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Bob – It becomes more clear (to me), every day, that even though > we all speak English in the US, Canada, UK, and Australia, what > the doctors tell us about sleep disorders, and the treatment we > receive, in each country is noticeably different. > Take Frankie, for example, in the UK. She appears to have > central apnea and the NHS just lets her drop by the wayside?!?!? > Any idea of what they do about CA in Australia (or Canada)? > Noone from Australia (or Canada) has responded to her posts. > Maybe the word ‘distilled’ and ‘demineralized’ mean different > things in Australia than the US. But, I doubt it. > IMHO you received a lot of questionable information from your > sleep doctor. Does he have any kind of certification to be a > sleep doc, or don’t they have that sort of thing in Australia? > As any kind of doctor, he should know the difference between > distilled water and demineralzed water, as indicated by Lee. So a > real (good) sleep doc, should know it. > IIRC, Legionaires disease was first discovered in the US, at an > American Legion Convention in a particular hotel. IIRC it was > associated with their refrigerated air conditioning system. > I was not aware of one person giving another person Legionaires > disease. However, it has occurred more than once in the US in > large groups. > Every post I’ve ever read here indicated that their User Manual > indicated distilled water. Mine does. What does your manual say? > IMHO, the use of demineralized water would be totally > inconsistent with trying to avoid any kind of ‘disease’. And > throwing away any unused distilled water is a waste of money.
As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (4 years). In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness.
> The bottom line is to do what you feel is appropriate for your > well being (both physical and psychological). > Bob in Aus wrote: > > I was a bit on the lazy side as well until it was put into terms that I now
understand that it is not laziness but a necessity. I recently had a follow-up with my sleep doc and he explained to me
why….
Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. Empty out any remaining water in the humidifier on a daily basis. The reason he gave was simply de-mineralised water will harbour the
least
amount of bacteria, and will not leave any residue in the chamber (well,
not
any, but the least amount) Chuck out the remaining every morning as the Legionella (sp?) virus can
kill
you! Here in Australia, we hear of several (up to 10) per year cases of legionnaires disease, basically a virus that kills people. The source is usually traced to contaminated water in cooling systems in large office buildings, shopping centres or other public buildings. I think that by chucking out a bit of water each day, rather than
breathing
in a potential source for (often Fatal) infection for 7 1/2 hours a day
a > > simple and worthwhile procedure. > > Put in these terms, that is a pretty good incentive for me to keep my > > humidifier clean! > > Bob in Aus > > "Tchmuzk" <tchm…@surfbest.net
wrote in message
> > news:be143p$og8$1@news.chatlink.com… > >>I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA > >>told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am,
I never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced hot air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
I wish your doctor would explain why demineralized water is better than distilled water. Chemically, I believe that distilled water is as close to pure water that you can get, also that it is totally sterilized during distillation, which is not the case for demineralized water. I use distilled because it does not leave any residue upon evaporation, and I clean it out every two or three months. Tap water should be fine, except for the heavy mineral deposits over time. You can use vinegar to remove them periodically. — Glenn
Response:
"Lee Babcock" <leebabc…@pathcom.com
wrote
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Quick wrote: > > "Bob in Aus" <bREMOVEo…@norcom.net.au.remove.me
wrote
> > > Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. > > I always thought distilled water *was* de-mineralised? > > Can somebody elaborate on the differences? I suppose there > > is a difference in the process to produce it? > > -Quick > Distilled water is de-mineralized among other things, but de-mineralized > water is water that was passed through a mechanical filter to remove the > minerals. > The heat of the distillation process also kills bacteria and the > evaporation of the condesation of the vapour leaves you with just water. > Regards > Lee in Toronto
So this is what confused me. From Bob’s post his doctor told him that de-mineralised water would have less chance of being or getting biologically contaminated. Was it a typo? -Quick
Response:
Bob – It becomes more clear (to me), every day, that even though we all speak English in the US, Canada, UK, and Australia, what the doctors tell us about sleep disorders, and the treatment we receive, in each country is noticeably different. Take Frankie, for example, in the UK. She appears to have central apnea and the NHS just lets her drop by the wayside?!?!? Any idea of what they do about CA in Australia (or Canada)? Noone from Australia (or Canada) has responded to her posts. Maybe the word ‘distilled’ and ‘demineralized’ mean different things in Australia than the US. But, I doubt it. IMHO you received a lot of questionable information from your sleep doctor. Does he have any kind of certification to be a sleep doc, or don’t they have that sort of thing in Australia? As any kind of doctor, he should know the difference between distilled water and demineralzed water, as indicated by Lee. So a real (good) sleep doc, should know it. IIRC, Legionaires disease was first discovered in the US, at an American Legion Convention in a particular hotel. IIRC it was associated with their refrigerated air conditioning system. I was not aware of one person giving another person Legionaires disease. However, it has occurred more than once in the US in large groups. Every post I’ve ever read here indicated that their User Manual indicated distilled water. Mine does. What does your manual say? IMHO, the use of demineralized water would be totally inconsistent with trying to avoid any kind of ‘disease’. And throwing away any unused distilled water is a waste of money. As far as cleaning any part of the humidifier, tube, mask system, there isn’t any real reason to clean it at all. You’re inhaling the same air you breath if you are awake, but it is filtered by the blower filter. The distilled water vapor it picks up is, by definition, bacteria free. If you were to search the archives, you’d find that in the last 2 1/2 years, what I have indicated here is the prevailing opinion from long term users (
4 years).
In addition, there have been link to studies/tests about the impossibility of a heated humidifier and distilled water cauing any kind of illness. The bottom line is to do what you feel is appropriate for your well being (both physical and psychological). – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Bob in Aus wrote:
I was a bit on the lazy side as well until it was put into terms that I now understand that it is not laziness but a necessity. I recently had a follow-up with my sleep doc and he explained to me why…. Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. Empty out any remaining water in the humidifier on a daily basis. The reason he gave was simply de-mineralised water will harbour the least amount of bacteria, and will not leave any residue in the chamber (well, not any, but the least amount) Chuck out the remaining every morning as the Legionella (sp?) virus can kill you! Here in Australia, we hear of several (up to 10) per year cases of legionnaires disease, basically a virus that kills people. The source is usually traced to contaminated water in cooling systems in large office buildings, shopping centres or other public buildings. I think that by chucking out a bit of water each day, rather than breathing in a potential source for (often Fatal) infection for 7 1/2 hours a day a simple and worthwhile procedure. Put in these terms, that is a pretty good incentive for me to keep my humidifier clean! Bob in Aus "Tchmuzk" <tchm…@surfbest.net wrote in message news:be143p$og8$1@news.chatlink.com… I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am, I never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced hot air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am, I never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced hot air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
I was a bit on the lazy side as well until it was put into terms that I now understand that it is not laziness but a necessity. I recently had a follow-up with my sleep doc and he explained to me why…. Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. Empty out any remaining water in the humidifier on a daily basis. The reason he gave was simply de-mineralised water will harbour the least amount of bacteria, and will not leave any residue in the chamber (well, not any, but the least amount) Chuck out the remaining every morning as the Legionella (sp?) virus can kill you! Here in Australia, we hear of several (up to 10) per year cases of legionnaires disease, basically a virus that kills people. The source is usually traced to contaminated water in cooling systems in large office buildings, shopping centres or other public buildings. I think that by chucking out a bit of water each day, rather than breathing in a potential source for (often Fatal) infection for 7 1/2 hours a day a simple and worthwhile procedure. Put in these terms, that is a pretty good incentive for me to keep my humidifier clean! Bob in Aus "Tchmuzk" <tchm…@surfbest.net
wrote in message
news:be143p$og8$1@news.chatlink.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am,
I
never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem? I have heated humidity, but I don’t turn on the heat now that my forced
hot
air is off for the summer. Joe
Response:
I’ve been on CPAP for about 3-4 months now. When I got my stuff, my DMA told me to use distilled water only in my humidifier. Lazy SOB that I am,
I
never got any and have been using tap water since day one. Is this a real problem?
http://www.talhost.net/sleep/cpap.htm#humidifiers — Beth in Australia =================== FAQ for alt.support.sleep-disorder can be found here http://talhost.net/sleep this site is a work in progress – feel free to submit info/articles Remove my name to reply
Response:
"Bob in Aus" <bREMOVEo…@norcom.net.au.remove.me
wrote Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water.
I always thought distilled water *was* de-mineralised? Can somebody elaborate on the differences? I suppose there is a difference in the process to produce it? -Quick
Response:
Quick wrote:
"Bob in Aus" <bREMOVEo…@norcom.net.au.remove.me wrote Use de-mineralised water, not tap water or distilled water. I always thought distilled water *was* de-mineralised? Can somebody elaborate on the differences? I suppose there is a difference in the process to produce it? -Quick
Distilled water is de-mineralized among other things, but de-mineralized water is water that was passed through a mechanical filter to remove the minerals. The heat of the distillation process also kills bacteria and the evaporation of the condesation of the vapour leaves you with just water. Regards Lee in Toronto —–= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =—– http://www.newsfeeds.com – The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! —–== Over 80,000 Newsgroups – 16 Different Servers! =—–
Response: